The breakdown of Yugoslavia and the ensuing war has called into question many formerly uncontested principles of international law. Perhaps the most far‐reaching challenge to the traditional international law doctrine was brought about by the NATO intervention in Kosovo. Many authors cite this event as a proof that a new right to humanitarian intervention is evolving or has already come into being. The aim of this article is to show that conventional positions have been abandoned far too easily in this context. Not only is this change of position unwarranted on legal grounds but it is also counterproductive on the factual level. Despite all its shortcomings the prohibition of the use of force may constitute in the end a better protection for the weak than its abandonment prompted by an over‐enthusiastic belief in the virtues of the intervenor.
20 March 2012 in Journal of Conflict and Security Law
The introduction of the Responsibility to Protect (R2P) concept is an example for a very successful case of norm entrepreneurship in international law. Seemingly against all odds, a vague political slogan has gained, within a decade, nearly a worldwide support. After the success of NATO-led Libya intervention ‘Unified Protector’ the bulk of the critics with regard to this concept appear to have been muted. In this article, it will be examined what are the ingredients for success for such a norm creation initiative. It will be evidenced that, equally as was the case with regard to the crafting of the self-determination norm, political rhetoric can solidify to legal principle. With regard to R2P, at the beginning of the 21st century, time was very propitious for such a development as there was a widespread conviction that international law had to be ‘humanized’. <!---->
24 January 2009 in Chinese Journal of International Law
The Kosovo problem represents a formidable occasion to re-examine some basic tenets of international law, such as the so-called right to humanitarian intervention, the right to self-determination and the right of recognition. It will be shown here, however, that many proposals suggesting the need of a radical departure from traditional positions are ill-conceived. Nonetheless, it is the uniqueness of many facets of the Kosovo problem that requires the analyst to look for new solution. It is now up to the International Court of Justice to show the way in a politically much loaded case. In particular, the right to self-determination should find a re-interpretation corresponding to the needs of the twenty-first century.
The Ukrainian crisis poses a new challenge of an extraordinary dimension to traditional international law. Many well-established concepts of international law have been put to the test. For some, in the wake of the Kosovo advisory opinion a new international law is in the making and the Ukrainian crisis is only a further episode in a longer lasting process pointing in the same direction. For others, the Ukraine case is absolutely particular and in this context historical considerations should prevail over legal dogmatism. It is argued here that traditional international law is very well suited to deal with the Ukraine case. It is further submitted that international law as it stands is flexible enough to cater to the needs of all parties involved. While the concept of territorial sovereignty is not negotiable, there are plenty of instruments and procedures available that should not only guarantee full protection of the Russian speaking groups within the Ukrainian State but also the actual promotion of their rights.
The endorsement/affirmation of the Global Compact on Migration and the Global Compact for Refugees in December 2018 has been accompanied by an intense discussion about the need to introduce new norms in these fields and about the actual legal force of the respective provisions. There was and there persists an open contrast between the openly declared non‐bindingness of these Compacts and the widespread fear that they would either severely constrain national sovereignty in highly delicate areas or dilute arduously achieved standards (especially with regard to refugee law). Eventually, this whole discussion leads to the question about the meaning and the status of soft law in international law. With regard to the European Union, the transformative impact of the Global Compacts will depend on whether the EU further proceeds on its path of “emancipation” from international law while internally finding no consensus on the values here at issue.