This paper makes the strong, fact-based case for a large-scale transformation of the current corpus of scientific subscription journals to an open access business model. The existing journals, with their well-tested functionalities, should be retained and developed to meet the demands of 21st-century research, while the underlying payment streams undergo a major restructuring. There is sufficient momentum for this decisive push toward open access publishing. The diverse existing initiatives must be coordinated so as to converge on this clear goal. The international nature of research implies that this transformation will be achieved on a truly global scale only through a consensus of the world’s most eminent research organizations. All the indications are that the money already invested in the research publishing system is sufficient to enable a transformation that will be sustainable for the future. There needs to be a shared understanding that the money currently locked in the journal subscription system must be withdrawn and re-purposed for open access publishing services. The current library acquisition budgets are the ultimate reservoir for enabling the transformation without financial or other risks. The goal is to preserve the established service levels provided by publishers that are still requested by researchers, while redefining and reorganizing the necessary payment streams. By disrupting the underlying business model, the viability of journal publishing can be preserved and put on a solid footing for the scholarly developments of the future.
This paper makes the case for stronger engagement of libraries and consortia when it comes to negotiating and drafting offsetting agreements. Two workshops organized by the Efficiencies and Standards for Article Charges (ESAC) initiative in 2016 and 2017 have shown a clear need for an improvement of the current workflows and processes between academic institutions (and libraries) and the publishers they use in terms of author identification, metadata exchange and invoicing. Publishers need to invest in their editorial systems, while institutions need to get a clearer understanding of the strategic goal of offsetting. To this purpose, strategic and practical elements, which should be included in the agreements, will be introduced. Firstly, the 'Joint Understanding of Offsetting', launched in 2016, will be discussed. This introduces the ‘pay-as-you-publish’ model as a transitional pathway for the agreements. Secondly, this paper proposes a set of recommendations for article workflows and services between institutions and publishers, based on a draft document which was produced as part of the 2nd ESAC Offsetting Workshop in March 2017. These recommendations should be seen as a minimum set of practical and formal requirements for offsetting agreements and are necessary to make any publication-based open access business model work
Dedicated funds for Open Access publishing have been a strategic instrument at German university libraries for many years. As the number of Open Access publications grows dynamically, the question arises as to whether the processes of handling article processing charges (APC) are being sustainably organised among libraries and publishers so as to enable a full transition to Open Access. Max Planck Digital Library processes about 600 invoices for Open Access articles per year centrally on behalf of Max Planck researchers. This paper contains a description of the individual steps required in order to assume charges centrally as well as the barriers emerging during this process. It is shown that the main desiderata for the establishment of smooth and scalable processes are the optimisation of article submission systems, better author identification and assignment, and improved reporting
Die Wissenschaft generiert von Jahr zu Jahr mehr Ergebnisse in Form von Publikationen. Besonders rasant wachsen die frei zugänglichen digitalen Veröffentlichungen. Open Access wird dabei zunehmend als qualitativ ebenbürtig zu den herkömmlichen Wegen der wissenschaftlichen Kommunikation erachtet, wie die ebenfalls rasch steigende Zahl der Zitierungen von Open-Access- Publikationen nahelegt. Der vorliegende Beitrag dokumentiert den derzeitigen Wandel in der Wissenschaftskommunikation zunächst allgemein anhand der umfassenden Datenbestände des Web of Science. Auch die spezifischeren Erfahrungswerte der Max-Planck-Gesellschaft untermauern das Ergebnis, dass Open Access aus der Wissenschaftskommunikation nicht mehr wegzudenken ist. Einen regelrechten Umbruch schließlich signalisiert der Erfolg der Mega-Zeitschrift PLoS ONE. Diese erst 2006 gegründete virtuelle und interdisziplinäre Fachzeitschrift erreicht heute, gemessen an der Zahl der Veröffentlichungen, die weltweit größte Verbreitung aller wissenschaftlichen Periodika und bestätigt das quantitative und qualitative Wachstum von Open Access auf eindrückliche Weise. Wissenschaftliche Bibliotheken müssen sich auf diesen Wandel einstellen und die Chancen zur Mitgestaltung ergreifen.