Surf therapy is increasingly being used as an intervention to address various health problems, including psychological symptoms. Although recent research supports the positive impact of surf therapy on psychological outcomes, it is unclear whether these outcomes differ between men and women. This study compared changes in depression/anxiety (Patient Health Questionnaire-4), positive affect (Positive and Negative Affect Schedule), and pain (Numerical Pain Rating Scale) between U.S. service men and women (N = 74) during six weekly surf therapy sessions. Overall, participants reported decreased depression/anxiety (p < 0.001) and increased positive affect (p < 0.001), but no change in pain rating following each session (p = 0.141). Significant gender differences were found in the magnitude of changes in depression/anxiety (B = −1.01, p = 0.008) and positive affect (B = 4.53, p < 0.001) during surf sessions, despite no differences in pre-session scores on either outcome. Women showed greater improvements in depression/anxiety and positive affect compared with men—an important finding, given that surfing and military environments are often socially dominated by men. Future research is needed to replicate these findings in other samples, extend this research to other underrepresented populations, and identify barriers and facilitators of the sustainable implementation of surf therapy across populations.
Many active duty service members suffer from major depressive disorder (MDD). Although traditional treatments exist, alternative approaches may also be effective in treating depressive symptoms. Previous research has shown that physical activity has significant positive effects on depression symptoms in individuals with MDD, and that these benefits may be enhanced when physical activity occurs in a natural environment. Even though physical activity (i.e., hiking, walking) in natural environments has been shown to reduce depressive symptoms, water-based activity occurring in a natural environment (e.g., surfing) may produce even greater improvements in depressive symptoms. We detail an ongoing randomized controlled trial (RCT) comparing the efficacy of surf therapy and hike therapy with respect to immediate and longer-term psychological, physical, and functional outcomes in active duty service members with MDD. We describe the methodological development of this RCT evaluating novel treatment approaches and discuss considerations for evaluating physical activity interventions in a naturalistic setting.
1 December 2024 in Psychological Trauma: Theory, Research, Practice, and Policy
Major depressive disorder (MDD) and posttraumatic stress disorder (PTSD) are commonly comorbid mental health disorders. Exercise performed in the natural environment has shown promise in relieving symptoms of each disorder separately; however, the effectiveness has seldom been studied in comorbid populations. Data were derived from a randomized controlled trial of surf and hike therapy for active duty service members with MDD (N = 95). In this study, participants were grouped by comorbidity status (MDD, n = 37; MDD-PTSD, n = 58). Clinician-administered and self-reported measures were completed at preprogram, postprogram, and 3-month follow-up; a brief depression/anxiety measure was completed before and after each session. Multilevel modeling results showed clinically significant decreases in depression severity across participants from pre- to postprogram (p < .001) and within exercise sessions (p < .001), with no further change through follow-up. No significant differences emerged in depression severity change over time by comorbidity status, intervention condition, or their three-way interaction. Those with PTSD showed reductions in posttraumatic stress symptoms from pre- to postprogram (p < .001), which did not differ by intervention condition; gains were maintained at follow-up. Remission rates from MDD and PTSD diagnoses (if applicable) were significant from pre- to postprogram for both MDD-only and MDD-PTSD groups (p < .001). These improvements were maintained at 3 months. Both surf and hike therapies can improve MDD and PTSD symptoms, regardless of comorbidity status, suggesting utility of these interventions among service members with one or both disorders. (PsycInfo Database Record (c) 2024 APA, all rights reserved).
Despite effective psychotherapy options for posttraumatic stress disorder (PTSD), some patients do not fully respond, and even among those reporting substantial improvement, residual symptoms following treatment are common. Psychiatric conditions frequently co-occur with PTSD, yet research on residual symptoms among comorbid samples is lacking. This study examined residual symptoms of PTSD and depression among 71 active duty service members with PTSD and comorbid major depressive disorder (MDD). As part of a clinical trial, participants were randomized to cognitive processing therapy (CPT) or a novel treatment designed to address PTSD and comorbid MDD, behavioral activation-enhanced CPT (BA + CPT). Analyses compared individual residual symptoms between treatments and groups based on PTSD and MDD diagnostic status at posttreatment. For both PTSD and MDD, the conditional probabilities for each residual symptom did not differ between CPT and BA + CPT, suggesting treatment type did not influence which symptoms persisted. For the 36 service members who lost their PTSD diagnosis at posttreatment, conditional probabilities of residual PTSD symptoms were highest for sleep problems, concentration difficulties, and hypervigilance; for MDD symptoms, conditional probabilities were highest for sleep problems, concentration difficulties, and low energy. These most common residual symptoms were identical for the 31 service members who lost their MDD diagnosis at posttreatment. Residual symptoms observed among service members with PTSD and comorbid MDD mirrored those commonly identified among single disorder PTSD or MDD samples. Identifying and addressing residual symptoms most meaningful to patients will maximize benefit from PTSD treatment.