Elspeth McCartney

Prof. Elspeth McCartney

orcid

Research Focus & Metrics

Academic Career Length

28Years (1999-Present)

(Calculated once Scilit publication data is synced: current year − year of first publication + 1)

Representative Publications

View All Publications
25 April 2018 in International Journal of Language & Communication Disorders
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
PDF file
SESusan H. Ebbels
Susan H. Ebbels
EMElspeth McCartney
Elspeth McCartney
VSVicky Slonims
Vicky Slonims
JDJulie E. Dockrell
Julie E. Dockrell
CNCourtenay Frazier Norbury
Courtenay Frazier Norbury
Background: Paediatric speech and language therapist (SLT) roles often involve planning individualized intervention for specific children, working collaboratively with families and education staff, providing advice, training and coaching and raising awareness. A tiered approach to service delivery is currently recommended whereby services become increasingly specialized and individualized for children with greater needs.Aims: To stimulate discussion regarding delivery of SLT services by examining evidence regarding the effectiveness of (1) intervention for children with language disorders at different tiers and (2) SLT roles within these tiers; and to propose an evidence‐based model of SLT service delivery and a flowchart to aid clinical decision‐making.Methods & Procedures: Meta‐analyses and systematic reviews, together with controlled, peer‐reviewed group studies where recent systematic reviews were not available, of interventions for children with language disorders are discussed, alongside the differing roles SLTs play in these interventions. Gaps in the evidence base are highlighted.Main Contribution: The service‐delivery model presented resembles the tiered model commonly used in education services, but divides individualized (Tier 3) services into Tier 3A: indirect intervention delivered by non‐SLTs, and Tier 3B: direct intervention by an SLT. We report evidence for intervention effectiveness, which children might best be served by each tier, the role SLTs could take within each tier and the effectiveness of these roles. Regarding universal interventions provided to all children (Tier 1) and those targeted at children with language weaknesses or vulnerabilities (Tier 2), there is growing evidence that approaches led by education services can be effective when staff are highly trained and well supported. There is currently limited evidence regarding additional benefit of SLT‐specific roles at Tiers 1 and 2. With regard to individualized intervention (Tier 3), children with complex or pervasive language disorders can progress following direct individualized intervention (Tier 3B), whereas children with milder or less pervasive difficulties can make progress when intervention is managed by an SLT, but delivered indirectly by others (Tier 3A), provided they are well trained and supported, and closely monitored.Conclusions & Implications: SLTs have a contribution to make at all tiers, but where prioritization for clinical services is a necessity, we need to establish the relative benefits and cost‐effectiveness at each tier. Good evidence exists for SLTs delivering direct individualized intervention and we should ensure that this is available to children with pervasive and/or complex language disorders. In cases where service models are being provided which lack evidence, we strongly recommend that SLTs investigate the effectiveness of their approaches.

1 June 2005 in Journal of Speech, Language, and Hearing Research
Verified
Journal Article
Closed access
PDF file
WCWendy Cohen
Wendy Cohen
AHAnn Hodson
Ann Hodson
AOAnne O'HAre
Anne O'HAre
JBJames Boyle
James Boyle
TDTariq Durrani
Tariq Durrani
JWJocelynne Watson
Jocelynne Watson
Seventy-seven children between the ages of 6 and 10 years, with severe mixed receptive-expressive specific language impairment (SLI), participated in a randomized controlled trial (RCT) of Fast ForWord (FFW; Scientific Learning Corporation, 1997, 2001). FFW is a computer-based intervention for treating SLI using acoustically enhanced speech stimuli. These stimuli are modified to exaggerate their time and intensity properties as part of an adaptive training process. All children who participated in the RCT maintained their regular speech and language therapy and school regime throughout the trial. Standardized measures of receptive and expressive language were used to assess performance at baseline and to measure outcome from treatment at 9 weeks and 6 months. Children were allocated to 1 of 3 groups. Group A ( n =23) received the FFWintervention as a home-based therapy for 6 weeks. Group B ( n =27) received commercially available computer-based activities designed to promote language as a control for computer games exposure. Group C ( n =27) received no additional study intervention. Each group made significant gains in language scores, but there was no additional effect for either computer intervention. Thus, the findings from this RCT do not support the efficacy of FFW as an intervention for children with severe mixed receptive-expressive SLI.

1 July 2007 in Health Technology Assessment
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
PDF file
JBJ Boyle
J Boyle
EMElspeth McCartney
Elspeth McCartney
JFJ Forbes
J Forbes
AOA O'HAre
A O'HAre
Health Technology Assessment Volume: 11, Issue: 25, Published in July 2007

4 November 2016 in International Journal of Language & Communication Disorders
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
PDF file
CMCristina McKean
Cristina McKean
JLJames Law
James Law
KLKaren Laing
Karen Laing
MCMaria Cockerill
Maria Cockerill
JAJan Allon-Smith
Jan Allon-Smith
JFJoan Forbes
Joan Forbes
Effective co-practice is essential to deliver services for children with speech, language and communication needs (SLCN). The necessary skills, knowledge and resources are distributed amongst professionals and agencies. Co-practice is complex and a number of barriers, such as ‘border disputes’ and poor awareness of respective priorities, have been identified. However social–relational aspects of co-practice have not been explored in sufficient depth to make recommendations for improvements in policy and practice. Here we apply social capital theory to data from practitioners: an analytical framework with the potential to move beyond descriptions of socio-cultural phenomena to inform change. Co-practice in a local authority site was examined to understand: (1) the range of social capital relations extant in the site's co-practice; (2) how these relations affected the abilities of the network to collaborate; (3) whether previously identified barriers to co-practice remain; (4) the nature of any new complexities that may have emerged; and (5) how inter-professional social capital might be fostered. A qualitative case study of SLCN provision within one local authority in England and its linked NHS partner was completed through face-to-face semi-structured interviews with professionals working with children with SLCN across the authority. Interviews, exploring barriers and facilitators to interagency working and social capital themes, were transcribed, subjected to thematic analysis using iterative methods and a thematic framework derived. We identified a number of characteristics important for the effective development of trust, reciprocity and negotiated co-practice at different levels of social capital networks: macro—service governance and policy; meso—school sites; and micro—intra-practitioner knowledge and skills. Barriers to co-practice differed from those found in earlier studies. Some negative aspects of complexity were evident, but only where networked professionalism and trust was absent between professions. Where practitioners embraced and services and systems enabled more fluid forms of collaboration, then trust and reciprocity developed. Highly collaborative forms of co-practice, inherently more complex at the service governance, macro-level, bring benefits. At the meso-level of the school and support team network there was greater capacity to individualize co-practice to the needs of the child. Capacity was increased at the micro-level of knowledge and skills to harness the overall resource distributed amongst members of the inter-professional team. The development of social capital, networks of trust across SLCN support teams, should be a priority at all levels—for practitioners, services, commissioners and schools.

12 October 1999 in International Journal of Language & Communication Disorders
Verified
Journal Article
Closed access
PDF file
EMElspeth McCartney
Elspeth McCartney
A systems approach is used to examine the barriers to collaboration found in the working practices of speech and language therapists and teachers. Functional, structural and systems-environment barriers are found, but few process barriers, which may explain why good collaborative practice can be found in the field. The differences that serve as barriers are listed and discussed, with a view to fostering mutual understanding between teachers and speech and language therapists.

31 August 2010 in Developmental Medicine & Child Neurology
Verified
Journal Article
Closed access
PDF file
JBJames Boyle
James Boyle
EMElspeth McCartney
Elspeth McCartney
AOAnne O’hAre
Anne O’hAre
JLJames Law
James Law