S. Beth Bierer

Dr. S. Beth Bierer

orcid

Research Focus & Metrics

Academic Career Length

23Years (2004-Present)

(Calculated once Scilit publication data is synced: current year − year of first publication + 1)

Representative Publications

View All Publications
1 March 2010 in Academic Medicine
Verified
Journal Article
Closed access
SBS. Beth Bierer
S. Beth Bierer
HCHuiju Carrie Chen
Huiju Carrie Chen
Scholarly concentrations (SCs) are elective or required curricular experiences that give students opportunities to study subjects in-depth beyond the conventional medical curriculum and require them to complete an independent scholarly project. This literature review explores the question, "What impact do SC programs have on medical students?" In 2008, the authors retrieved published articles using Medline, ERIC, and PsycINFO electronic databases and scanned reference lists to locate additional citations. They extracted data from selected articles using a structured form and used Kirkpatrick's evaluation model to organize learner outcomes into four categories: reactions, learning, behavior, and results. Of 1,640 citations, 82 full-text papers were considered, and 39 studies met inclusion criteria. Most articles described SC programs that offered students research opportunities. Fourteen articles provided evidence that SC experiences influenced students' choice of clinical specialty or fostered their interest in research. Eight articles reported that SCs improved students' understanding of research principles and methods. Nineteen articles reported publications and presentations to document students' ability to apply acquired knowledge and skills. Twelve studies confirmed the entry of SC graduates into academic medicine with continued engagement in research or success in obtaining grant funding. Students' criticisms focused on requiring research during clinical training and the effort needed to complete scholarly projects. The diversity of articles and variable results prevent definitive conclusions about the value of SCs. Findings suggest several implications for future SC program evaluations and educational research. The authors advocate increased rigor in evaluation designs to demonstrate SCs' true impact.

30 July 2021 in Medical Teacher
Verified
Journal Article
Closed access
DTDario Torre
Dario Torre
NRNeil E. Rice
Neil E. Rice
ARAnna Ryan
Anna Ryan
HBHarold Bok
Harold Bok
LDLuke J. Dawson
Luke J. Dawson
Cees van der VleutenCees van der Vleuten
Cees van der Vleuten
Programmatic assessment is a longitudinal, developmental approach that fosters and harnesses the learning function of assessment. Yet the implementation, a critical step to translate theory into pr...

19 July 2014 in Advances in Health Sciences Education
Verified
Journal Article
Closed access
PDF file
SBS. Beth Bierer
S. Beth Bierer
RPRichard A. Prayson
Richard A. Prayson
EDElaine F. Dannefer
Elaine F. Dannefer

30 January 2020 in Medical Education
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
PDF file
S. (Suzanne) SchutS. (Suzanne) Schut
S. (Suzanne) Schut
SHSylvia Heeneman
Sylvia Heeneman
SBS. Beth Bierer
S. Beth Bierer
EDErik Driessen
Erik Driessen
JTJan Van Tartwijk
Jan Van Tartwijk
Cees van der VleutenCees van der Vleuten
Cees van der Vleuten
Objectives: Programmatic assessment attempts to facilitate learning through individual assessments designed to be of low‐stakes and used only for high‐stake decisions when aggregated. In practice, low‐stake assessments have yet to reach their potential as catalysts for learning. We explored how teachers conceptualise assessments within programmatic assessment and how they engage with learners in assessment relationships. Methods: We used a constructivist grounded theory approach to explore teachers' assessment conceptualisations and assessment relationships in the context of programmatic assessment. We conducted 23 semi‐structured interviews at two different graduate‐entry medical training programmes following a purposeful sampling approach. Data collection and analysis were conducted iteratively until we reached theoretical sufficiency. We identified themes using a process of constant comparison. Results: Results showed that teachers conceptualise low‐stake assessments in three different ways: to stimulate and facilitate learning; to prepare learners for the next step, and to use as feedback to gauge the teacher's own effectiveness. Teachers intended to engage in and preserve safe, yet professional and productive working relationships with learners to enable assessment for learning when securing high‐quality performance and achievement of standards. When teachers' assessment conceptualisations were more focused on accounting conceptions, this risked creating tension in the teacher‐learner assessment relationship. Teachers struggled between taking control and allowing learners' independence. Conclusions: Teachers believe programmatic assessment can have a positive impact on both teaching and student learning. However, teachers' conceptualisations of low‐stake assessments are not focused solely on learning and also involve stakes for teachers. Sampling across different assessments and the introduction of progress committees were identified as important design features to support teachers and preserve the benefits of prolonged engagement in assessment relationships. These insights contribute to the design of effective implementations of programmatic assessment within the medical education context.

1 December 2023 in Journal of Graduate Medical Education
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
PDF file
JLJeremy M. Lipman
Jeremy M. Lipman
CCColleen Y. Colbert
Colleen Y. Colbert
RARendell Ashton
Rendell Ashton
JFJudith French
Judith French
CWChristine Warren
Christine Warren
JSJames K. Stoller
James K. Stoller
Background Aligning resident and training program attributes is critical. Many programs screen and select residents using assessment tools not grounded in available evidence. This can introduce bias and inappropriate trainee recruitment. Prior reviews of this literature did not include the important lens of diversity, equity, and inclusion (DEI). Objective This study’s objective is to summarize the evidence linking elements in the Electronic Residency Application Service (ERAS) application with selection and training outcomes, including DEI factors. Methods A systematic review was conducted on March 30, 2022, concordant with PRISMA guidelines, to identify the data supporting the use of elements contained in ERAS and interviews for residency training programs in the United States. Studies were coded into the topics of research, awards, United States Medical Licensing Examination (USMLE) scores, personal statement, letters of recommendation, medical school transcripts, work and volunteer experiences, medical school demographics, DEI, and presence of additional degrees, as well as the interview. Results The 2599 identified unique studies were reviewed by 2 authors with conflicts adjudicated by a third. Ultimately, 231 meeting inclusion criteria were included (kappa=0.53). Conclusions Based on the studies reviewed, low-quality research supports use of the interview, Medical Student Performance Evaluation, personal statement, research productivity, prior experience, and letters of recommendation in resident selection, while USMLE scores, grades, national ranking, attainment of additional degrees, and receipt of awards should have a limited role in this process.

15 July 2015 in Journal of General Internal Medicine
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
PDF file
SBS. Beth Bierer
S. Beth Bierer
EDElaine F. Dannefer
Elaine F. Dannefer
JTJohn E. Tetzlaff
John E. Tetzlaff
Remediation in the era of competency-based assessment demands a model that empowers students to improve performance.