Department of Allied Health Professionals, Midwifery and Social Work, School of Health and Social Work, University of Hertfordshire, Hatfield AL10 9AB, UK
Prof. Brian Littlechild
Department of Allied Health Professionals, Midwifery and Social Work, School of Health and Social Work, University of Hertfordshire, Hatfield AL10 9AB, UK
This article presents findings from a survey of the experiences of child protection workers in England when working with parents who exhibit aggression and violence. This work explores the effects on workers in their professional lives, and on themselves and their families in their private lives. The article examines workers’ thoughts and experiences about the effects of parental hostility on workers’ ability to protect children. The article also details workers’ experiences of the nature and effectiveness of training and support in this area. These findings are then examined in the light of the results of an analysis of the literature, including the findings from serious case review (SCR) reports in England (official inquiries into the causes of child deaths where the children are known to social and health services). The majority of the 590 respondents in the survey were social workers (n = 402; 68%), reflecting the fact that case management of child protection cases in the United Kingdom is the responsibility of social workers working in statutory agencies. This article addresses, from a consideration of the secondary analysis and the original research findings from the survey, how individual workers, managers, and agencies can best understand and then respond effectively to aggressive parental behaviors.
This article examines the relationship between the causes and effects of fear in child protection social workers, and the effects of risk assessment and risk management policies on this area of work. The focus on risk assessment and risk management has become a major area of attention within practice, policy and management of child protection work in the UK in recent years. Concepts of risk as constructed by the media, government and the public are increasingly impacting upon professional practices. This article examines the basis and validity of risk assessments in the social professions field, and particularly within the child protection arena. The article goes on to examine the experiences of fear arising from the risk agenda, which affects frontline workers, managers and child protection agencies. This agenda arises from centrally produced risk assessment frameworks, alongside unrealistic expectations from central government of prediction of risk by the use of current risk assessment tools. Such controlling policies from central government can lead to fear and anxiety in social work professionals of not assessing and eliminating risk, as the government and their employing agencies are expecting them to do. The article also proposes that this risk agenda fails to address a key element in the assessment of risk – how social workers experience threats and stress in their work, and the pressures they can be subject to within it, particularly in relation to violence and threats from parent service users where their children are being investigated for possible child abuse.
Background: The NSF specifies that mental health service providers should have a locally agreed proforma for assessing risk. Risk assessment proformas (RAPs) currently in use vary considerably in both structure and content. This study describes some similarities and differences. Method: We requested a copy of each provider trust's RAP. These were assessed across a range of structural characteristics, including layout, design, data coding, and were also studied for their content. Results: Some consistency was seen in the themes addressed: suicide/self harm, risk to others (notably violence) and vulnerability were well represented. Several additional themes were notable by their absence. There was general conformity in the way in which data was coded, with most using tick box categories. However, there were striking differences in layout quality and usability and many common problems were identified. Conclusions: RAPs as currently used in NHS mental-health practice vary in structure, content, length and quality. We question (i) the most common approaches in recording risk data in RAPs, and (ii) whether the focus on three domains of risk acts to neglect other, less dramatic, areas. Risk assessment procedures need to be critically evaluated and the introduction of standardized tools would be advantageous in this respect. Declaration of interest: This work was supported by NHS R&D Support funding awarded to Hertfordshire Partnership NHS Trust.
Original article can be found at : http://informahealthcare.com/ Copyright Informa [Full text of this article is not available in the UHRA]Background : Risk assessment is a routine part of mental health services, with professionals being required to complete a risk assessment proforma (RAP) for every patient under their care. Aims : This study was designed to investigate staff attitudes to, and beliefs about, the completion of risk assessment paperwork. Method : We surveyed 300 professionals across one county to examine: (i) the amount of time taken to complete RAPs; (ii) attitudes towards completing such paperwork; and (iii) beliefs about the quality and usefulness of the information recorded. Results : We found considerable variation in the amount of time taken to complete RAPs. The median time was 18 minutes with doctors spending significantly less time than nurses. More favourable attitudes towards RAPs were seen in nurses than in doctors, in spite of the increased time spent completing them. Moreover, nurses also held more positive views about the value and benefit of the information recorded in RAPs. Conclusions : The findings suggest that RAP completion may account for a significant proportion of staff time. Inter-professional differences in belief and attitude were prominent and this should be an important consideration in the evolution of risk assessment procedures