Municipal mergers are typically contentious and polarizing issues among both citizens and politicians. In deciding on these, municipal-level referendums are often commissioned by municipal councils. Referendums, though, are also per se polarizing processes that only exacerbate an already polarizing issue. Adding deliberation to referendum processes has been shown in previous studies to be a more democratically sustainable process than mere referendums. In this study, we explore the use of mixed deliberation between citizens and politicians within a municipal merger process in the municipality of Korsholm in Finland, one year before a referendum on the issue occurred. The deliberations were two-hour sessions in February 2018, with local politicians present in each discussion group. Using pre- and post-deliberation surveys, we trace how citizens (n = 117) engaging in deliberation developed their social trust, political trust, and political efficacy during deliberation. Generally, we expected that all of these would be strengthened in deliberation. The results, however, reveal only a few statistically significant effects, some of which ran contrary to expectations.
Local consultative referendums are a widely used democratic innovation. Nevertheless, there is still limited knowledge about the local effects following a referendum, especially in terms of how the public reactions varies given if a citizen has been on the winning or on the losing side of the referendum. The purpose with this study is therefore to add to this line of research by assessing how a local referendum about a municipal merger affects external political efficacy and political trust within a local community. By analysing two cross-sectional datasets collected in a bilingual Finnish municipality before a merger referendum, in 2018 (N = 6,686), and after the referendum, in 2020 (N = 3,133), as a pseudo-experiment of effects of a municipal merger, we show that the aggregated levels of external political efficacy and political trust have increased and vary based on being on the winning or losing side of the referendum.
20 September 2021 in Innovation: The European Journal of Social Science Research
With deliberative democracy becoming increasingly incorporated into political processes, the instances of citizens and politicians meeting in deliberation, so-called mixed deliberations, is increasing too. While these are important steps towards more deliberative systems, the mixed deliberation setting nonetheless introduces certain risks regarding equality. Citizens and politicians have different deliberative capacities, which could affect the process of deliberation. Moreover, political inequalities such as gender gaps may be more evident in deliberations where politicians are present. This study focuses on a series of mixed deliberations in 2018 about a proposed municipal merger in Finland. Using content analysis of speech acts (N = 3404) as well as pre- and post-deliberation surveys (N = 225), we analyze patterns according to participant status (politician/citizen) and gender regarding dominance, deliberative discussion quality, and impact on internal and external efficacy. The findings show that politicians dominated the discussions and achieved a higher deliberative quality than citizens. The findings also revealed that women achieved higher deliberative quality in their speech acts.
2 May 2025 in Political Science Research and Methods
Voters’ issue preferences are key determinants of vote choice, making it essential to reduce measurement error in responses to issue questions in surveys. This study uses a MultiTrait MultiError approach to assess the data quality of issue questions by separating four sources of variation: trait, acquiescence, method, and random error. The questions generally achieved moderate data quality, with 76% on average representing valid variance. Random error made up the largest proportion of error (23%). Error due to method and acquiescence was small. We found that 5-point scales are generally better than 11-point scales, while answers by respondents with lower political sophistication achieved lower data quality. The findings indicate a need to focus on decreasing random error when studying issue positions.
An updated version is published in the journal Survey Research Methods https://ojs.ub.uni-konstanz.de/srm/article/view/8278.Declining response rates have remained a major worry for survey research in the 21st century. Inthe past decades, it has become harder to convince people to participate in surveys in virtuallyall Western nations. Worrisome, declining willingness to participate in surveys (i.e., responsepropensities) may increase the risk of extensive nonresponse bias. Therefore, a better understandingof which factors are associated with survey nonresponse and its impact on nonresponsebias is paramount for any survey researcher interested in accurate statistical inferences. Knowingwhich factors relate to low response propensities enables appropriate models of nonresponseweights and aids in identifying which groups to tailor efforts for turning nonrespondents intorespondents. This manuscript draws on previous theories and research on nonresponse and investigatesthe risk of nonresponse bias, both cross-sectionally and over time, in two time seriescross-sectional studies administered in Sweden (the National SOM Surveys 1993-2023 and theSwedish National Election Study 2022). Capitalizing on available registry data on all sampledpersons and their corresponding neighborhood-level contextual data, a meta-analytical analysisof nine years of data collection finds that educational attainment, age, and country of birthare among the strongest predictors of response propensities. However, contextual factors—suchas living in socially disadvantaged neighborhoods—also predict willingness to participate insurveys. Furthermore, utilizing the three decades of data, the growing nonresponse could beidentified to be wholly attributable to a deteriorating survey climate rather than birth cohortreplacement or immigration patterns.
Kokoomateos avaa tutkimukseen perustuvan näkymän siihen, millaisin eväin vuoden 2023 eduskuntavaaliehdokkaat lähtivät tavoittelemaan paikkaa suomalaisen vallankäytön keskiössä. Teos pureutuu suomalaisen ehdokaskampanjoinnin ja poliittisen edustuksen ytimeen: miten ehdokkaat kampanjoivat, mistä he saavat tukea, millaiset arvot heitä ohjaavat, keitä he kokevat edustavansa ja millaisessa toimintaympäristössä vaalityö nykyisin tapahtuu. Voimistuva yhteiskunnallinen polarisaatio, sosiaalisen median aikakausi ja kampanjoinnin siirtyminen yhä enemmän verkkoon muodostavat vaalien keskeisen taustan. Tähän kehitykseen liittyvät myös vaalihäirinnän lisääntyminen sekä Suomen ehdokaskeskeinen vaalijärjestelmä. Yhdessä ne luovat monikerroksisen kentän, jossa ehdokkaiden tarvitsemat taloudelliset ja sosiaaliset resurssit jakautuvat epätasaisesti. Teoksen empiirinen perusta on Eduskuntavaaliehdokkaat 2023 -kyselyaineisto, jonka avulla tutkijat valottavat kampanjoiden painotuksia, sosiaalisen median strategioita sekä ehdokkaiden poliittisia arvoja ja käsityksiä demokratiasta. Tulokset tuovat esiin suomalaisen demokratian vahvuuksia, mutta myös ilmentymiä kehityksestä, joka voi tulevina vuosina kaventaa poliittisen edustuksen monimuotoisuutta.