In the last five years, European research and innovation programmes have prioritised the development of online catalogues and tools (handbooks, models, etc.) to facilitate the implementation and monitoring of Nature-Based Solutions (NBS). However, only a few catalogues and toolkits within European programmes are directly related to mainstreaming of NBS for food production (i.e., edible NBS). Therefore, the main aim of this paper is to present existing NBS tools through the eyes of productive urban landscapes. We reviewed 32 projects related to NBS and 50 tools were identified and characterised. Then, the six tools already available and provided indicators were further analysed in terms of their format and knowledge domains. Our main conclusion demonstrates that there is a lack of tools capable of supporting users for planning and implementing edible NBS; calculating the food potential of a city and/or of individual edible NBS, including the needed resources for implementation and operation (water, nutrients, energy); and assessing their urban design value, environmental and socio-economic impacts. Moreover, when they do exist, there is a resistance to share the models and equations behind the tools to allow other projects to reuse or validate them, a fact which is contrary to the open science principles upheld by many public research agencies.
29 April 2025 in Journal of Environmental Management
Decentralised systems to recover alternative sources of water (wastewater, rainwater, and seawater) can reduce water scarcity in rural areas by closing water loops while improving the local economy. However, their implementation commonly faces difficulties owing to social, legislative, technical, and economic barriers that must be assessed in local contexts. In this study, the implementation of six decentralised solutions (DCS) that were previously tested to recover water and other products was evaluated at 26 replication sites worldwide. Small, isolated locations were considered for site selection. They generally have scarce water resources and/or inappropriate water sanitation systems, and a high dependency on external regions. A quantitative feasibility assessment methodology (QFAM) developed in a previous study was used to evaluate the potential implementation of the DCS by quantifying relevant data regarding social, legislative, technical, and economic factors collected from the sites. From the results obtained in the overall assessment, the sites could be divided into two main groups: European sites that showed many similarities, especially in terms of common legal frameworks ruled by EU directives, and non-European sites that showed higher variations in local specificities. Most EU replicability sites showed high feasibility scores; however, for non-European sites, the results were distributed between high and medium feasibility scores. High scores were significantly influenced by high social and legislative feasibility assessments obtained at most sites. However, a general lack of understanding of the specificities of decentralised systems in local authorities and administrations was detected, which can be a significant barrier. Technical and economic assessments sometimes showed medium or low scores owing to certain limitations in the production of some circular products and the lack of financial instruments at some sites to reduce the initial investment for the implementation of DCS.
In the last five years, European research and innovation programmes have prioritised the development of online catalogues and tools (handbooks, models, etc.) to facilitate the implementation and monitoring of Nature Based Solutions (NBS). However, only a few catalogues and toolkits within European programmes are directly related to mainstreaming of NBS for food production (i.e., edible NBS). Therefore, the main aim of this paper is to present existing NBS tools through the eyes of productive urban landscapes. We reviewed 32 projects related to NBS and 50 tools were identified and characterised. Then, the 6 tools already available, and providing indicators, were further analysed in terms of their format and knowledge domains. Our main conclusion demonstrates that there is a lack of tools capable of supporting users for planning and implementing edible NBS, calculating the food potential of the city and/or of individual edible NBS, including the needed resources for implementation and operation (water, nutrients, energy), and assessing their urban design value, environmental and socio-economic impacts. And when they do exist, there is a resistance to share the models and equations behind the tools to allow other projects to reuse or validate them, fact which is contrary to Open Science principles stood up by many research public agencies.