This article investigates the pedagogical and digital practices of vocational education and training teachers, offering comparative insights from both teacher and student perspectives. To this end, two questionnaires were constructed for teachers and students and then validated by means of inter-judge procedures and expert review. The questionnaires were administered to representative samples of 158 teachers and 309 students in intermediate and higher vocational education and training programs in the Spanish region of Catalonia. Thanks to institutional collaboration, it was possible to obtain both samples by a non-probability sampling technique. The results obtained from the quantitative analyses performed show that while most vocational education and training teachers utilize a combination of active and lecture-based methods, less than a third incorporate online tools, prioritizing institutional platforms. Although both teachers and students acknowledge a diversity of teaching strategies, the latter, particularly female students and those in advanced years or on dual programs, tend to be more critical of the effectiveness of the teaching strategies employed compared to their teachers. The findings underscore the need for vocational education and training programs to enhance digital tool integration and address the varying perceptions of teaching effectiveness to better meet students’ expectations and needs.
In the search for solutions to national skill formation challenges, the central and northern Europeans models of good practices in dual vocational education and training (VET) permeated the imaginary of the southern countries. Particularly, the German dual VET system has been predominant in the discourse of policy-makers. This research analyses the role played by the European Union (EU) in the promotion of this model as the reference for the reforming Member States during the policy transfer stage of cross-national attraction. This paper develops a reflexive Thematic Analysis among the fundamental documentation related to VET resulting from the EU Governance Triangle. Its aim is to interpret the EU proposal for the reform of VET, with a focus on the characteristics which shape the way in which the training is developed. This Thematic Analysis reveals that the EU promotes a VET training model based in work-based learning as a pillar, preferably articulated in the form of apprenticeships. This, along with the general principles for the regulation of apprenticeships promoted by the EU, proves the agency role exercised by the EU in the dissemination of dual VET as a model of good practice.
Here, we present a systematic review of the literature on Early Leaving from Education and Training (ELET), which uses the life course paradigm as an explanatory model or approach. This review has returned little in the way of scientific literature, although interest in the topic has been growing in recent years, which addresses the ELET process from different points of view. First, we highlight the means that this review provides to contextualize ELET in relation to new age-specific norms, reflecting on the process that has led to it. In addition, this review suggests that it is increasingly important to change the focus of research on ELET, exploring the process within a framework of complex trajectories, including the possibility of returning once ELET has occurred.
30 June 2023 in Revista Española de Educación Comparada
Las altas tasas de desempleo estructural en los países d sur europeo, junto a la carencia de profesionales de titulaciones de nivel medio, están generando la puesta en marcha de reformas en sus sistemas de formación profesional (FP). Estas reformas, impulsadas desde la Unión Europea, han utilizado como modelo de referencia el sistema dual centroeuropeo. No obstante, esta transferencia implica procesos de adopción, adaptación y transformación en su implantación, donde se presentan diferentes retos, dificultades y desafíos entre los actores implicados. Este artículo se basa en una revisión sistemática de la literatura de los retos y dificultades a los que se enfrentan los sectores públicos y privados en la implantación del modelo dual. En la misma se ha seguido el protocolo PRISMA y las propuestas de O’Neill & Booth (2017) para el uso de Nvivo en revisiones sistemáticas. La búsqueda y creación del corpus bibliográfico se realizó a través de WoS-Main Collection, Scopus y ProQuest. Los resultados sistematizan los retos y dificultades que la literatura académica identifica en lo referente a la colaboración público-privada para el correcto funcionamiento de la FP dual, claves en los procesos de implementación. Estos giran en torno al acceso, la cooperación en red, el desarrollo del currículo, la tensión entre productividad y formación y la respuesta a las recesiones económicas. La literatura revisada advierte de que cualquier intento de reformar la FP siguiendo el modelo dual centroeuropeo conlleva múltiples desafíos contextuales que dificultan una transferencia directa. El diálogo social emerge como herramienta fundamental para una exitosa implement
6 September 2024 in Research in Comparative and International Education
This paper examines the adoption of dual VET in Spain as a process of educational policy transfer. Using Phillips and Ochs’ (2003, 2004) policy transfer spectrum and decision-making classification and Perry and Tor’s (2008) model of transfer forms, the study relies on semi-structured interviews with key decision-makers in the Spanish central government and the Autonomous Communities of the Basque Country and Andalusia. Findings indicate that EU diffusion activities facilitated adoption, involving first-order learning. Initially, adoption at the central level was uninformed, driven by quick-fix decisions, but later shifted to informed transfer through second- and third-order learning, enhancing realism. In Andalusia and the Basque Country, decision-making consistently adapted to the real context, progressing from second- to third-order learning. Ultimately, this analysis concludes that dual VET adoption at the central, Andalusian, and Basque levels falls between ‘negotiated under constraint’ and ‘borrowed purposefully’, though not at the same point.
RESUMEN Las reformas neoliberales no sólo han impactado en el trabajo docente sino también en el discurso y las prácticas de sus asociaciones políticas. Las evidencias muestran una situación controversial del asociacionismo docente, por un lado, afectado por la crisis de las organizaciones tradicionales y por otro, reconfigurado a partir de nuevas formas de participación política. En este sentido, este estudio etnográfico buscó analizar la experiencia de participación en una asociación que surge como fuerza política alternativa a la crisis de la asociación tradicional docente. Los resultados muestran que participar implica asumir responsabilidades en una militancia política que se ha tensionado por las oportunidades coyunturales del país y los discursos feministas. Se discuten las implicancias de la militancia para el fenómeno de asociacionismo docente.