UV/Vis spectrometers are powerful tools for online monitoring of wastewater constituents and processes. However, most studies only focus on typical parameters such as COD and TSS. This work presents a multi-parameter approach for calibration of a UV/Vis spectrometer for online monitoring of sewer systems. Parameters studied here are: soluble and total COD, nitrate, ammonium, sulphate and orthophosphate as well as the sulphide species total dissolved sulphide, bisulphide and hydrogen sulphide, since they are one of the main causes for odour and corrosion in sewer systems. Two calibration methods are compared: multiple linear regression (MLR) included in the manufactureŕs software, and partial least square (PLS) computed with the pls package of the R library. Performance of the methods is evaluated for calibration and validation datasets employing four different criteria: relative root mean square error (RMSErel), RMSE-observations standard deviation ratio (RSR), Nash-Sutcliffe efficiency (NSE) and percent bias (PBias). A method-parameter dependency was revealed during the calibration phase, but, when predicting new data, the PLS method showed higher robustness for almost all parameters. Both methods were able to predict concentration trends associated with sewer processes, some of which are strongly correlated to the sulphide species.
Hydrogen sulphide (H2S) emissions are one of the major problems associated with sewer networks. This gas, with its characteristic smell of rotten eggs is highly toxic and leads to the corrosion of sewer infrastructures. To protect cities and ensure the safety of sewer workers, sewers are commonly monitored using H2S gas sensors. In this work, three commercial H2S gas sensors for air quality monitoring were compared at two different sites in Berlin, Germany. Two of the sensors provide online access to data, while the other one is a data logger. Moreover, based on statistical measures (RMSE, MAE, MB, and a graphical analysis), we evaluated whether a rotation/exchange between data logger (reference) and online sensors is possible without significant differences in the gas measurements. Experimental evaluation revealed that measurement differences are dependent on the H2S concentration range. The deviation between sensors increases as the H2S concentration rises. Therefore, the interchange between reference and online sensors depends on the application site and the H2S levels. At lower ranges (0–10 ppm) there were no observed problems. Finally, to support practitioners on-site, a management procedure in the form of a decision-making tool is proposed for assessing whether gas sensors should be exchanged/rotated.
Hydrogen sulfide (H2S) related to wastewater in sewer systems is known for causing significant problems of corrosion and odor nuisance. Sewer systems severely affected by H2S typically rely on online H2S gas sensors for monitoring and control. However, these H2S gas sensors only provide information about the H2S emission potential at the point being monitored, which is sometimes inadequate to design control measures. In this study, a comparison of three market-ready online sensors capable of liquid-phase H2S detection in sewer systems was assessed and compared. Two of the three sensors are based on UV/Vis spectrophotometry, while the other adapted the design and principles of a Clark-type electrochemical microsensor. The H2S measurements of the sensors were statistically compared to a standard laboratory method at first. Following that, the performance of the online sensors was evaluated under realistic sewer conditions using the Berlin Water Company (BWB) research sewer pilot plant. Test applications representing scenarios of typical H2S concentrations found in sulfide-affected sewers and during control measures were simulated. The UV/Vis spectrometers showed that the performance of the sensors was highly dependent on the calibration type and measurements used for deriving the calibration function. The electrochemical sensor showed high sensitivity by responding to alternating anaerobic/anoxic conditions simulated during nitrate dosing. All sensors were prone to measurement disturbances due to high amounts of sanitary solids in wastewater at the study site and required continuous maintenance for reliable measurements. Finally, a summary of the key attributes and limitations of the sensors compared for liquid phase H2S detection is outlined.
Hydrogen sulphide (H2S) emissions in sewer systems lead to several problems such as corrosion, odour nuisances, and health damage to sewer workers. Although the gas is formed in the liquid phase, its effects are noticeable when released into the sewer atmosphere. Until recently, the lack of analytical procedures for continuous monitoring of H2S in the liquid phase, as well as its toxicity, have challenged the quantification of the mass transfer coefficient under real conditions. Because of this, most studies have mainly focused on batch experiments with artificial wastewater and/or oxygen. The aim of this study was to experimentally determine the overall mass transfer coefficient for H2S during intermittent pumping events common in actual sewer systems, using the two-film theory approach and employing online sensors for liquid and gas phase measurements. The mass transfer coefficient was quantified by carrying out 21 experiments with actual wastewater in a 25 m long gravity pipe of a sewer pilot plant located in Berlin (Germany). Results show that the corrected mass transfer coefficient (KLa20) during a pumping event ranged between 0.1 and 8 h−1 with a median value of 4.2 h−1, within the range of the results obtained by the most common empirical models.