Fine effects that influence the variations of the reaction constants sf in LFER log k = sf(Nf + Ef) have been summarized here. Increasing solvent polarity in the series of binary mixtures increases the solvolysis rates for the same factor for all benzhydryl derivatives in which the solvation of the leaving group moiety in the transition state is substantial, i.e., log kvs.Ef correlation lines are parallel (same sf). For the substrates in which the demand for solvation of the leaving groups moiety is reduced, (e.g., carbonates) sf parameters decrease as the fraction of the water in a given solvent/water mixture increases (log kvs.Ef plots converge), due to decreasing solvation of the electrofuge moiety toward bigger electrofugality. The abscissa of the intersection of the converging plots might indicate the critical electrofugality above which the solvolysis rates should not depend of the water fraction. Larger reaction constant sf indicate later transition state for structurally related substrates only, while sf parameters for structurally different substrates cannot be compared likely due to different intrinsic barriers. Inversion in relative abilities of leaving groups is possible if they have similar reactivities and are characterized with different reaction constants.
This paper is dedicated to Professor Herbert Mayr on the occasion of his 70th birthday. A short review of the development of nucleofugality and electrofugality scales based on solvolysis rates of benzhydryl derivatives is presented. Accordingly, the rate of the heterolytic step in the SN1 displacement reaction and the leaving group ability (nucleofugality) in a given solvent are related with the special linear free-energy relationship (LFER) equation: log k = s f (N f + E f). The impact of electronic effects in the leaving group (nucleofuge) on the overall SN1 reactivity of the substrate is given. The importance of inductivity, resonance, polarity and field effects in the leaving group moiety in the transition state is analyzed. Also, the effect of the negative hyperconjugation and the influence of other electronic effects in the leaving group on the height of the reaction intrinsic barrier are considered. 1 Introduction 2 Development of the Nucleofugality Scale 3 Inductive and Resonance Effects 4 Negative Hyperconjugation 5 Intrinsic Barrier 6 Conclusions
The possibility of employing quantum mechanical computations to predict solvolysis rates of benzhydryl aryl/alkyl (Ar/R) carbonates and to determine nucleofugalities of various Ar/R carbonate leaving groups in terms of Nf values is examined. Since unassisted SN1 transition states of neutral substrates cannot be optimized by using implicit solvation models, a model reaction that includes anchimerically assisted heterolysis of 2-oxyethyl Ar/R carbonates is utilized to determine the relative reactivities of both benzhydryl Ar/R carbonate substrates and Ar/R carbonate leaving groups. Very good linear correlations have been obtained between activation free energies of the model reaction, calculated by using the M06-2X method in conjunction with the IEFPCM solvation model, and activation free energies in the literature for solvolysis of the corresponding benzhydryl Ar/R carbonates in a given solvent. The slopes of close to unity demonstrate that calculated and measured relative reactivities of the Ar/R carbonate leaving groups are practically the same. Very good agreement between experiment and theory has enabled extending the nucleofugality (Nf) scale established by Mayr and co-workers (Acc. Chem. Res., 2010, 43, 1537–1549) with numerous new Ar/R carbonate leaving groups.
Nucleofugalities of pentafluorobenzoate (PFB), 2,4,6-trifluorobenzoate (TFB), 2-nitrobenzoate, and 3,5-dinitrobenzoate (DNB) leaving groups have been derived from the solvolysis rate constants of the corresponding X,Y-substituted Z-benzhydryl benzoates in 60 % and 80 % aqueous acetonitrile and 60 % aqueous acetone, by applying the LFER equation: log k = f s (Ef + Nf). The experimental barriers (ΔG‡ exp) for solvolyses of 13 dianisylmethyl Z-substituted benzoates in these solvents correlate very well with the ΔH‡ calc of the model epoxy ring formation (calculated earlier by the B3LYP-PCM quantum-chemical method). Using the ΔG‡ exp vs. ΔH‡ calc correlation, and taking f s based on similarity, the nucleofugality parameters for about 70 benzoates have been determined in 60 % and 80 % aqueous acetonitrile and 60 % aqueous acetone. Z-Substituents on the phenyl ring have larger impact on the solvolytic reactivity in the less polar solvent than in the more polar solvent due to the more carbocation-like transition state. (doi: 10.5562/cca2179
24 May 2021 in Journal of Physical Organic Chemistry