The increasing number of smart devices installed in our homes poses privacy risks for inhabitants and visitors. However, individuals face difficulties counteracting privacy intrusions due to missing controls, incorrect mental models, and limitations in their level of expertise. We present PriKey, a concept for device-independent and easy-to-use tangible smart home privacy mechanisms. PriKey is the key to privacy protection: it supports users in taking control over their privacy through meaningful, tangible interactions. Using a Wizard-of-Oz prototype, we explored users’ perceptions regarding PriKey (N = 16). We then compared PriKey to an equivalent smartphone app (N = 32), focusing on visitors. Participants perceived PriKey as engaging, intuitive, and benevolent. Their privacy considerations were based on personal and contextual factors. While most participants preferred the smartphone app, others clearly favored PriKey. Our results indicate that tangible privacy is a noteworthy approach for future smart home privacy mechanisms.
Video-based online meetings and, ultimately, the amount of private information that is shared – intentionally or accidentally – increased as a result of the COVID-19 pandemic. For example, online teaching might reveal lecturers’ private environment to students or business meetings might provide insights about employees’ family relationships. This raises the need to understand users’ perception towards privacy intrusion during online video conferences to inform concepts that better protect meeting participants’ privacy. We present the results of an online survey (N = 140) in which we investigate user stories of privacy-invasive situations in their homes during such meetings. Our results show that online meetings reveal private information that would not have become available during physical meetings. This often involves third parties (e.g., children, spouse, colleague), who might not even be aware of this. We discuss potential means to support users in protecting their and others’ privacy before, during, and after video-based online meetings.
Existing software-based smart home privacy mechanisms are frequently indirect and cumbersome to use. We developed PriKey, a tangible privacy mechanism for smart homes that offers intuitive, device-independent, sensor-based, and user-centric privacy control. To render our concept comprehensible, we implemented a demonstration consisting of Wizard-of-Oz prototypes that show the envisioned form factor, size, and portability of our system, as well as a larger functional prototype of PriKey, which enables control of privacy-invasive sensors integrated into two exemplary smart devices, i.e., a smart speaker and a tablet.