Managing invasive Indo-Pacific lionfish (Pterois volitans and P. miles) in the Western Atlantic Ocean is beyond the capacity of natural resource organizations alone. In response, organizations have mobilized members of the public and citizen scientists to help. We used a structured survey to assess the activities and perceptions of 71 organizations that engage the public and citizen scientists in lionfish research and management throughout the invaded range of the Western Atlantic. Five case studies were also conducted that exemplified varied and multi-pronged approaches to engagement of the public and citizen scientists in lionfish control, monitoring, and knowledge-sharing. The public has been engaged to some extent in every approach, but organizations most frequently indicated engaging members of the public in raising awareness, promoting consumption, organized culling/removal, tournaments, and data collection. Sixty-five percent of organizations surveyed engaged the public in data collection, and data collection was ranked as the scientific research activity in which the public is most often involved. Most organizations indicated their data has contributed to scientific publications, management, and government agency research and/or policy. Collectively these findings demonstrate the conservation value of citizen scientists to assist organizational efforts to control, manage, and study a large-scale marine invasion.
Invasive lionfish ( Pterois spp.) have rapidly spread across the Western Atlantic and Mediterranean Sea. They reproduce frequently and consume native marine life important to livelihoods and reef health. To combat the deleterious impacts of this species, management efforts in Belize and throughout the invaded range have included development of a food market for lionfish. To determine the viability of a food market for lionfish and marketing strategies to sell lionfish in Belize, we conducted nationwide, structured surveys with a representative sample of foreign tourists ( n = 400) and Belizean citizens and residents (BCRs) ( n = 400). We assessed knowledge about lionfish, attitudes towards purchasing lionfish and food neophobia (fear of trying new food) to predict willingness to consume lionfish and compared the two groups. We found no significant difference in awareness or knowledge about lionfish between foreign tourists and BCRs. However, foreign tourists were more willing to try lionfish and exhibited significantly less food neophobia than BCRs. BCRs were more likely to believe lionfish is unsafe to eat, and often believe it is unsafe to handle, which poses a barrier as this group reported that they typically prepare seafood themselves rather than dine at restaurants. Taste and health were the most common reasons both groups eat seafood. Health was noted more often by BCRs, and foreign tourists often stated they chose seafood because it is fresh and available locally. Just 15% of BCRs and 16% of tourists have tried lionfish, but 50% of BCRs and 74% of tourists would be willing to try lionfish, suggesting a significant opportunity to increase the consumption of lionfish. Synthesis and applications . Findings support the viability of marketing lionfish in Belize to both BCRs and tourists given effective outreach and provide lessons learned for similar efforts throughout the invaded range. Outreach to BCRs should include safe handling and emphasize that lionfish is safe to eat, as the misperception that it is not is a barrier to consumption. Comparing lionfish to snapper in taste and texture is a promising approach for marketing to BCRs, while taste, health and benefits to the reef and local fishers are motivating for BCRs and tourists. Read the free Plain Language Summary for this article on the Journal blog.
This report provides actionable guidance for scientists developing scientific tools that inform on-the-ground decision making. Scientific tools, in the context of this report, are technology or protocols that help practitioners collect and analyze their own data, and information products and web tools that practitioners could use to inform decisions. Engaging end-users and fellow experts is fundamental to the creation of useful scientific tools. Scientists can use clear and specific direction on action steps and activities to effectively engage with end-users and fellow experts during development. Our study explores lessons learned from six U.S. Geological Survey projects that designed and implemented engagement activities with end-users and experts to coproduce scientific tools for natural resource managers. U.S. Geological Survey teams engaged end-users and experts across the United States from Federal, State, and local governments; universities; Tribes; territories; and nongovernmental organizations in designing and developing scientific tools intended to support end-users in their work. An online survey with 98 participants measured satisfaction across several indicators of successful engagement, including engagement activity frequency, sufficient opportunities to provide feedback, feedback implementation, inclusion of necessary perspectives, and functionality of the tool for end-users. Semistructured interviews were held with project leads, during which the project leads reviewed a summary of the survey results. The project leads reflected on the engagement efforts used in their project, then described lessons learned from the engagement experience and participant feedback. Common themes for ensuring effective engagement identified through thematic analysis included engaging end-users during product conceptualization; establishing clear roles and expectations; considering who end-users are and how end-users may use the tool; recruiting participants through your network, boundary spanners, and leadership; understanding individual use cases; communicating how feedback was integrated into the product; and strategically using virtual meeting tools. This guide shares practical steps and exercises for planning and facilitating effective engagement based on lessons learned from project leads and case study summaries of each project.
Social network research often depends on the willingness of respondents to provide personal information about themselves and alters. Survey design strategies that increase willingness to share this information are necessary for social network research to be feasible, especially when name generators are used for sampling because rosters are unavailable. We conducted an experiment in which one group of respondents ( n = 94) received an online survey that included an example network map and the other group ( n = 100) received one that did not. Results show the map did not increase or decrease provision of network contacts nor influence the types of ties reported. Furthermore, respondents were reluctant to provide names and contact information of alters. Our study demonstrates the difficulty of collecting network information without a previously defined roster and an attempt to improve data collection through strategic survey design.