Activity cliffs (AC) are formed by pairs of structural analogues that are active against the same target but have a large difference in potency. While much of our knowledge about ACs has originated from the analysis and comparison of compounds and activity data, several studies have reported AC predictions over the past decade. Different from typical compound classification tasks, AC predictions must be carried out at the level of compound pairs representing ACs or nonACs. Most AC predictions reported so far have focused on individual methods or comparisons of two or three approaches and only investigated a few compound activity classes (from 2 to 10). Although promising prediction accuracy has been reported in most cases, different system set-ups, AC definitions, methods, and calculation conditions were used, precluding direct comparisons of these studies. Therefore, we have carried out a large-scale AC prediction campaign across 100 activity classes comparing machine learning methods of greatly varying complexity, ranging from pair-based nearest neighbor classifiers and decision tree or kernel methods to deep neural networks. The results of our systematic predictions revealed the level of accuracy that can be expected for AC predictions across many different compound classes. In addition, prediction accuracy did not scale with methodological complexity but was significantly influenced by memorization of compounds shared by different ACs or nonACs. In many instances, limited training data were sufficient for building accurate models using different methods and there was no detectable advantage of deep learning over simpler approaches for AC prediction. On a global scale, support vector machine models performed best, by only small margins compared to others including simple nearest neighbor classifiers. Graphical Abstract
Predicting the outcomes of organic reactions using data-driven approaches aids in the acceleration of research. In laboratory-scale experiments, only a small number of reaction data can be accessed for machine learning model construction, where reaction representations play a pivotal role in the success of model construction. Nevertheless, representation comparison for a small data set is not adequate. Herein, focusing on the enantioselectivity of phosphoric-acid-catalyzed reactions, various two-dimensional and three-dimensional reaction representations (descriptors) were compared. Overall, the concatenated form of the extended connectivity fingerprints showed the best predictive capability for the two types of data sets: high-throughput experimental data and manually collected literature data sets. Furthermore, highlighting the substructure contribution to the prediction outcome was shown to be informative for guiding catalyst development.
4 June 2020 in Industrial & Engineering Chemistry Research
Fourier-transform infrared (FTIR) spectroscopy can detect the presence of functional groups and molecules directly from a mixed solution of organic molecules. Although it is quite useful to monitor chemical reactions, quantitative analysis of FTIR spectra becomes difficult when various peaks of different widths overlap. To overcome this difficulty, we propose a chemometrics approach to accurately predict the concentration of components in chemical reactions, yet interpretable by humans. The proposed method first decomposes a spectrum into peaks with various widths by the wavelet transform. Subsequently, a sparse linear regression model is built using the wavelet coefficients. Models by the method are interpretable using the regression coefficients shown on Gaussian distributions with various widths. The interpretation is expected to reveal the relation of broad regions in spectra to the model prediction. In this study, we conducted the prediction of monomer concentration in copolymerization reactions of five monomers against methyl methacrylate by various chemometric approaches including conventional methods. A rigorous validation scheme revealed that the proposed method overall showed better predictive ability than various linear and non-linear regression methods. The visualization results were consistent with the interpretation obtained by another chemometric approach and qualitative evaluation. The proposed method is found to be useful for calculating the concentrations of monomers in copolymerization reactions and for the interpretation of spectra.
18 March 2025 in Journal of Chemical Information and Modeling
The prediction of molecular properties is essential in chemoinformatics and has many applications in drug discovery and materials design. Molecular representations play a key role in the prediction models to achieve high prediction accuracy. Nevertheless, appropriate molecular descriptors, including the utilization of conformational information, have been unclear due to a lack of systematic analysis of property prediction models and control. This study investigates the influence of using multiple conformers in machine learning-based property prediction, comparing two- and three-dimensional descriptors using three independent data sets: a large-scale quantum mechanical property, a medium-scale melting point, and small-scale enantioselective chemical reaction data sets. One unique aspect of this study is creating these carefully controlled data sets for models' performance evaluation in conformational diversity and the target property's dependence on conformation. Our findings show that using all available conformers as simple data augmentation consistently achieves high prediction accuracy among aggregation approaches, followed by mean aggregation. Furthermore, Uni-Mol, an end-to-end prediction model utilizing atomic coordinates and elements, combined with the ground-truth conformation, significantly outperformed traditional 2D and 3D descriptors and predicted conformational-sensitive properties with high accuracy. Although the prediction accuracy of the Uni-Mol model significantly decreased using the wrong conformers, it still outperformed two-dimensional extended connectivity fingerprints, which showed higher prediction accuracy than most of the tested 3D descriptors.