This study is based on field research conducted by an international team of researchers investigating the opportunities for social upgrading of smallholder farm owners and tenants and their workers in the Global South. The main objective has been to assess the influence of crop characteristics, end markets, and value chain governance (including product and process standards), as well as national political, economic, and cultural contexts, on the conditions of farmers and farmworkers. Accordingly, the selected crops differ along the axes of domestic versus international end markets and short versus long shelf-life: coffee (cash crop), rice (staple crop), and mangoes (perishable crop). The selected countries are Bangladesh, Brazil, Colombia, Ghana, India, Pakistan, and Vietnam. Our main findings relate to the importance of collective action by key stakeholders, including smallholders and a supportive state, for economic and social upgrading.
1 October 2018 in Journal of Social and Economic Development
The financial crisis of 2008 offers an ideal ‘critical moment’ to investigate the reproduction of hegemony. In contrast to the widely held belief that a crisis undermines the legitimacy, and thus the hegemony, of a particular group, this article shows how, before the current crisis, finance capital gained in strength through a series of financial crises, to the point where it had become hegemonic in a Gramscian sense. Using a rigorous conceptualization of hegemony, a detailed study of the five phases of crisis management since the outbreak of the 2008 crisis here reveals that finance capital has kept its central place in a financialized regime of accumulation, and that it has received continued support from most other fractions of capital. Its losses have been restricted to the area of passive support among the American public; whilst it has been able to rely on its institutional power and its ability to fund lobbying campaigns to maintain wider support. This has meant that the mixture of coercion and consensus underlying hegemony has shifted slightly towards coercion in relation to the general public. But finance capital's main message – that citizens have the right to keep their money and to invest it according to their preferences – continues to resonate with a sizeable portion of the American electorate. Therefore it is premature to suggest that finance capital has suffered a loss of hegemony.
Urban expansion creates potential for increased incomes among previously rural smallholders from sources other than traditional agriculture. Harnessing this potential, however, requires investments into agricultural upgrading or non-farm activities. The article addresses the question concerning to what extent these investments are realised in the peri-urban space of Bengaluru. Its answers are based on a review of the literature and extensive field surveys in two differentially developed districts assessing the smallholders’ economic situation in 2019 and as a recall in 2009. Our findings are that only a few smallholders were able to realise the peri-urban opportunities. Household income increased in real terms only by a little, especially from farming. Instead of a traditional farm to non-farm production linkage, surpluses from the non-farm sector were seen to meet the working capital needs of the farm sector. While physical access to formal financial institutions has significantly improved, formal borrowing is dominated by small-sized loans from registered self-help groups or traditional priority sector loans. Only a few households took up non-farm activities as many others failed to obtain sufficient credit and lacked knowledge about remunerative non-farm projects. Overall, rising outlays for education and health services leave little resources for any productive investments.