Fermi problems are real-context estimation tasks that are suitable for introducing open-ended problems in primary school education. To ensure their effective introduction in the classroom, teachers must have adequate proficiency to deal with them. One of the key aspects of problem-solving proficiency is flexibility, but there are few studies on flexibility in solving real-context problems. This study, based on an analysis of the errors made by 224 prospective teachers when solving a Fermi problem sequence, establishes performance levels. In addition, we define levels of flexibility in using multiple solutions across the sequence, which allows us to address the main objective: to study the relationship between performance and flexibility. We found that there are significant relationships between flexibility levels and the number and severity of errors made. Encouraging flexibility in prospective teachers may be an efficient way to improve their performance in solving real-context problems.
Fermi problems are useful for introducing modelling in primary school classrooms, although teachers’ difficulties in problem solving may hinder their successful implementation. These difficulties are associated with the modelling process, but also with the estimation and measurement skills required by Fermi problems. In this work, a specific categorization of errors for Fermi problems was established, and it allowed us to analyse the errors of N = 224 pre-service primary school teachers. The results showed that prospective teachers make a large number of errors when solving this type of task, especially conceptual ones, which are associated with the process of simplifying/structuring the real situation and the mathematization process. They also showed that there is a significant relationship between the characteristics of the problem context and the error categories. Knowing the types of errors that prospective teachers make and designing task sequences that make them emerge so that prospective teachers learn from them could be an effective way to improve initial teacher education in modelling and estimation problem solving.
29 April 2024 in Implementation and Replication Studies in Mathematics Education
Several studies confirm the importance of the role of students’ interest in learning mathematics. This article describes the process of conceptual replication of Rellensmann and Schukajlow’s (2017) research on how the connection to the reality of a mathematical problem affects the interest in solving it. Our study distinguishes between intramathematical problems, word problems and modelling problems. It was implemented with 80 Spanish ninth-grade students and 80 pre-service teachers. The results show that Spanish students are more interested in intramathematical problems and less interested in modelling problems, while pre-service teachers are more interested in problems connected to reality, especially word problems. We also provide data regarding the performance of students and prospective teachers, which is higher in word problems. In addition, we find that there are significant relationships between performance and task-specific interest. These results complement the original study, as they allow us to contrast whether there are differences with German students and to explain the German pre-service teachers’ judgements of students’ interest in problems with and without a connection to reality. The impact sheet to this article can be accessed at 10.6084/m9.figshare.25507636.
19 February 2025 in Journal of Mathematics Teacher Education
Modelling is an important mathematical competence in many curricula worldwide, in Secondary education but even in Primary Education. Fermi problems (FPs) are suitable activities for introducing mathematical modelling in Primary Education, as they present a real situation, without data, and ask for an estimate of an unattainable quantity. However, implementing such tasks is challenging for primary school teachers, partly due to some gaps in modelling-specific teacher knowledge. Previous studies show a relationship between pre-service teachers’ performance and flexibility in solving FPs. Still, the impact of other factors that may affect performance, particularly prior knowledge of measurement and measurement estimation (M&ME), has not been studied. We aim to characterise pre-service teachers’ prior M&ME knowledge and to find out what are the relationships between this knowledge, flexibility and performance in solving FPss. To address this, we present the design and validation of a test on M&ME knowledge that pre-service teachers (PSTs) subsequently took. A cluster analysis based on their answers allowed us to characterise three levels of prior knowledge. In addition, PSTs’ flexibility and performance in solving a sequence of FPs was analysed, finding that there are significant differences in performance according to their level of prior M&ME knowledge. However, prior knowledge does not influence flexibility. We further find that PSTs’ flexibility and prior M&ME knowledge explain an important part of their performance in solving FPs. The results may help to improve PSTs’ instruction on modelling problem-solving.
This work aims to examine how the learning of mathematics in early childhood is developed in different policies, particularly within the processes of formal education and care in early years institutions. A comparative analysis of early mathematics education policies across countries must consider cultural differences, teaching practice, structural differences and institutional framework conditions, as well as the initial training and professional knowledge of teachers and educators. Extracted from the official country regulations, the following pages include some of the main characteristics of the national systems of early childhood education and care (ECEC) in Portugal, Slovenia and Spain, as well as a comparison of the ECEC guidelines concerning mathematics education between these three countries. There is an international consensus on an approach to early mathematics education inspired by realistic mathematics education (RME), i.e., on the importance of working mathematically in context, as well as on the idea of doing so through play, developing the language to communicate mathematical ideas. However, we found that these three aspects are reflected very differently in the official regulations of the three countries: while in Spain the development is very detailed and emphasizes the holistic approach and the role of mathematics in exploring the environment, the Portuguese curriculum emphasizes the role of mathematics as a form of language. The Slovenian curriculum, at last, focuses on the concepts and procedures associated with each mathematical sense. Furthermore, there are structural features concerning the regulation and type of ECEC system that have an influence in the implementation of the curriculum.
1 April 2026 in EURASIA Journal of Mathematics, Science and Technology Education
Despite their potential to foster critical thinking, modelling tasks remain underrepresented in mathematics classrooms. Fermi problems (FPs), as open estimation tasks, are well-suited for introducing modelling in primary education. Given the growing presence of artificial intelligence (AI) in education, it is essential to understand how pre-service teachers (PSTs) engage with tools like ChatGPT in modelling contexts. This study analyses the use of ChatGPT by 133 PSTss solving FPs and examines how this use is shaped by problem complexity and prior experience. Through qualitative and quantitative analysis, three distinct profiles of AI use emerged—expert, assistant, and support—reflecting varying degrees of autonomy and delegation. Results show greater delegation to AI in more complex problems, while prior experience with outdoor problem-solving or ChatGPT fosters more autonomous engagement. These findings provide insights for integrating AI into mathematics education to support reflective, independent, and critical modelling practices.