A reliable lie-detection method would be extremely useful in many situations but especially in forensic contexts. This review describes and evaluates the range of methods that have been studied. Humans are barely able to pick up lies on the basis of nonverbal cues; they do so more successfully with systematic methodologies that analyze verbal cues and with physiological and neuroscientific methods. However, the rates at which people are able to detect lies are still well below the legal standard of “beyond a reasonable doubt.” This means that the utmost caution must be exercised when such methods are employed. In investigations where independent evidence exists, there is emerging evidence that interviews based on a free account followed by the gradual introduction of the evidence by investigators can reveal inconsistencies in a guilty interviewee’s account. Automated machine-learning methods also hold some promise.
Retrieval-induced forgetting (RIF) is a phenomenon where the retrieval of an item impairs memory for items associated to the retrieved item. This effect has been robustly demonstrated with a wide range of stimuli. A few studies have investigated this phenomenon with emotional memories for autobiographical life events and for pathology-specific memories in clinical populations. The present study investigated whether RIF would be observed for stimuli of positive and negative emotional valence in the normal population. On a recognition test, the effect was observed both on measures of accuracy and response time with neutral words, but no RIF was observed for words of negative and positive emotional valence. In addition, RIF was observed only for studied items and did not extend to all members of the studied categories. This observation was made possible by the use of a recognition task in the test phase, and is accounted for in terms of episodic inhibition (Racsmány & Conway, 2006 Racsmány, M. and Conway, M. A. 2006. Episodic inhibition. Journal of Experimental Psychology: Learning, Memory and Cognition, 32: 44–57. [Crossref], [PubMed], [Web of Science ®] [Google Scholar] ).
Schwartz ( 1999 Schwartz, B. L. 1999. Sparkling at the end of the tongue: The aetiology of tip-of-the-tongue phenomenology. Psychonomic Bulletin and Review, 6: 379–393. [Crossref], [PubMed], [Web of Science ®] [Google Scholar] , 2002 Schwartz, B. L. 2002. Tip-of-the-tongue states: Phenomenology, mechanism and lexical retrieval, London: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates Ltd. [Google Scholar] ) has claimed that tip-of-the-tongue states (TOTs) are universal. The studies reported in this paper examine this claim for illiterates, unschooled literates, and schooled readers, all speakers of an unwritten Guatemalan language. The first study showed that, although there was little evidence of a dedicated verbal expression for this state of consciousness in the Mayan language of Q'eqchi’, a majority of participants in all three groups recognised a description of the phenomenology associated with tip-of-the-tongue states. In two further studies it was shown that TOTs could be induced in all groups of participants, and that they were reliably resolved by the presentation of the words’ initials. Thus, even in the absence of an expression for “tip-of-the-tongue state”, the basic phenomenology and cueing properties of TOTs were similar to those reported in previous studies. However, only university-level participants reported partial knowledge of word targets they had failed to recall. The results are discussed from psycholinguistic and metacognitive perspectives, drawing a possible link between TOTs and epistemic curiosity.
There is agreement among researchers that no simple verbal cues to deception detectable by humans have been demonstrated. This paper examines the evidence for the most prominent current methods, critically considers the prevailing research strategy, proposes a taxonomy of lie detection methods and concludes that two common types of approach are unlikely to succeed. An approach to lie detection is advocated that derives both from psychological science and common sense: When an interviewee produces a statement that contradicts either a previous statement by the same person or other information the authorities have, it will in many cases be obvious to interviewer and interviewee that at least one of the statements is a lie and at the very least the credibility of the witness is reduced. The literature on Strategic Use of Evidence shows that features of interviews that foster such revelatory and self-trapping situations have been established to be a free account and the introduction of independent information late and gradually into the proceedings, and tactics based on these characteristics constitute the best current general advice for practitioners. If any other approach 1 day challenges this status quo, it is likely to be highly efficient automated systems.
Faulty eyewitness testimony can be a notorious source of mistakes in the legal system potentially leading to wrongful convictions and miscarriages of justice. The current study examined the knowledge of a sample of police officers (n = 270) and psychologists (n = 63) in Indonesia regarding factors known to influence the validity of eyewitness testimony given by adults and children. Previous studies have documented that police and psychologists in Western countries have less-than-optimal knowledge about the psychology of eyewitness testimony. Similarly, our non-Western sample also demonstrated a lack of knowledge that may be damaging in the legal context such as the belief that recall of minor details indicates accuracy of memory. For both adult and child eyewitnesses, the psychologists performed significantly better than the police but at the item level these differences were small in size. Intriguingly, we also found that psychologists were more likely than the police officers to endorse the item about repression of memories. The findings show the need for teaching on the psychology of eyewitness testimony for professional groups involved in the legal arena.