This paper examines the sources of uncertainty for the Forced Diffusion (FD) chamber soil respiration (Rs) measurement technique and demonstrates a protocol for uncertainty quantification that could be appropriate with any soil flux technique. Here we sought to quantify and compare the three primary sources of uncertainty in Rs: (1) instrumentation error; (2) scaling error, which stems from the spatial variability of Rs; and (3) random error, which arises from stochastic or unpredictable variation in environmental drivers and was quantified from repeated observations under a narrow temperature, moisture, and time range. In laboratory studies, we found that FD instrumentation error remained constant as Rs increased. In field studies from five North American ecosystems, we found that as Rs increased from winter to peak growing season, random error increased linearly with average flux by about 40% of average Rs. Random error not only scales with soil flux but scales in a consistent way (same slope) across ecosystems. Scaling error, measured at one site, similarly increased linearly with average Rs, by about 50% of average Rs. Our findings are consistent with previous findings for both soil fluxes and eddy covariance fluxes across other northern temperate ecosystems that showed random error scales linearly with flux magnitude with a slope of ~0.2. Although the mechanistic basis for this scaling of random error is unknown, it is suggestive of a broadly applicable rule for predicting flux random error. Also consistent with previous studies, we found the random error of FD follows a Laplace (double‐exponential) rather than a normal (Gaussian) distribution.
Summary: 1. A better understanding of temporal and spatial variability of soil CO2 fluxes is essential to improve model predictions of soil effluxes. To accomplish that goal, high‐frequency and long‐term data sets for model development and validation are needed. However, the cost and high maintenance associated with the current technology make high‐frequency measurements for small or large spatially distributed grids difficult to achieve. Here, we describe a new observational infrastructure for monitoring soil CO2 efflux, which is attractive because of its low cost and low power consumption compared to traditional methods.2. Three observational stations equipped with forced diffusion (FD) chambers were deployed in the summer of 2010 across a 1000‐km transect in Atlantic Canada. At half‐hourly resolution, each observational station recorded soil carbon dioxide (CO2) efflux from two flux chambers and from a suite of meteorological sensors and peripherals. Each station was equipped with telemetry, and data were continuously downloaded for c. 1 year.3. The average power consumption for each station was roughly a third of a LI‐COR LI‐8100 system. The FD chambers were approximately four times more affordable than conventional equipment and were also reliable with <1% of the data lost because of power failure.4. High‐frequency observations from the three sites showed that the systems were extremely dynamic, with CO2 efflux dependency to temperature and moisture on many time‐scales. For instance, the data showed pronounced increases in soil CO2 efflux after major rain events. The results from the FD chambers also highlighted the role of other biological and physical factors on soil CO2 efflux.5. Overall, this new method was very successful in key areas including survivability, management intensity and cost. The high‐frequency data hold many interesting features that are not captured in synoptic data sets and which will be useful for tuning our understanding of soil carbon dynamics.