In a recent paper, an elegant, efficient, and easy to apply transient-based leakage detection method was proposed. The method exploits the fact that friction and leakage damp the modes of transient waves in a different manner. The method involves six major assumptions. These are: (1) the periodic motion in time of each mode is linearly independent of all other modes; (2) the amplitude of the induced transient is small; (3) the magnitude of the leak is small in comparison with the flow rate; (4) the wall friction can be represented by the Darcy–Weisbach equation; (5) the transient is initiated by an instantaneous small amplitude disturbance; and (6) the pipe system is a simple reservoir–pipe–valve type system or reservoir–pipe–reservoir type system. These six assumptions are relaxed and the validity of the transient damping method is assessed. The analysis shows that the first four assumptions do not pose any serious restriction to the applicability of the damping rate method provided that the mathematical model, used to generate the transient head trace in the leak-free pipe, accurately represents the frictional damping in the system. On the other hand, Assumptions (5) and (6) restrict the applicability of the method to systems that do not involve internal boundary conditions, such as junctions and pumps, and to transients triggered by impulses whose duration is smaller than the wave travel time. Extension of this method to complex pipe systems requires that the linearized waterhammer equations are solved under more general initial and boundary conditions. In addition, more investigation in relation to the frequency content of the input signal and its importance in leakage detection is warranted. The general framework used to derive the damping rate method has led to an efficient and direct algorithm for identifying leaks and future research should seek ways to adapt this framework to more complex pipe systems.
A linear stability analysis of lateral motions in shallow flow open channels with a free surface is presented. Unlike previous studies, this work does not employ the rigid-lid assumption. Computations revealed that the rigid-lid assumption works well for weak shear flows and/or small Froude numbers. However, the validity of the rigid-lid assumption is reduced as the Froude number increases. Also, when Reynolds numbers are larger than 1,000, the stability domain is insensitive to the Reynolds number for all Froude numbers. The size of the stability domain is found strongly affected by the velocity and length scales of base velocity and the shape of the velocity profile. The analysis shows that the stability domains obtained by the Manning formula are larger than those obtained by the Chézy formula for the same Froude number. The analysis shows that a compound channel, whose floodplain has larger flow resistance than the main channel does, has larger lateral transport of flow mass, momentum, and energy.
Experimentally observed periodic structures in shallow (i.e. bounded) wake flows are believed to appear as a result of hydrodynamic instability. Previously published studies used linear stability analysis under the rigid-lid assumption to investigate the onset of instability of wakes in shallow water flows. The objectives of this paper are: (i) to provide a preliminary assessment of the accuracy of the rigid-lid assumption; (ii) to investigate the influence of the shape of the base flow profile on the stability characteristics; (iii) to formulate the weakly nonlinear stability problem for shallow wake flows and show that the evolution of the instability is governed by the Ginzburg–Landau equation; and (iv) to establish the connection between weakly nonlinear analysis and the observed flow patterns in shallow wake flows which are reported in the literature. It is found that the relative error in determining the critical value of the shallow wake stability parameter induced by the rigid-lid assumption is below 10% for the practical range of Froude number. In addition, it is shown that the shape of the velocity profile has a large influence on the stability characteristics of shallow wakes. Starting from the rigid-lid shallow-water equations and using the method of multiple scales, an amplitude evolution equation for the most unstable mode is derived. The resulting equation has complex coefficients and is of Ginzburg–Landau type. An example calculation of the complex coefficients of the Ginzburg–Landau equation confirms the existence of a finite equilibrium amplitude, where the unstable mode evolves with time into a limit-cycle oscillation. This is consistent with flow patterns observed by Ingram & Chu (1987), Chen & Jirka (1995), Balachandar et al. (1999), and Balachandar & Tachie (2001). Reasonable agreement is found between the saturation amplitude obtained from the Ginzburg–Landau equation under some simplifying assumptions and the numerical data of Grubĭsić et al. (1995). Such consistency provides further evidence that experimentally observed structures in shallow wake flows may be described by the nonlinear Ginzburg–Landau equation. Previous works have found similar consistency between the Ginzburg–Landau model and experimental data for the case of deep (i.e. unbounded) wake flows. However, it must be emphasized that much more information is required to confirm the appropriateness of the Ginzburg–Landau equation in describing shallow wake flows.
The convective instability boundary of a circular Couette flow in the annular region bounded by two co- or counter-rotating coaxial cylinders with angular velocities ω1 and ω2, respectively, is studied in the presence of an axial flow due to a constant axial pressure gradient and a radial flow through the permeable walls of the cylinders. A linear stability analysis is carried out for positive and negative radial Reynolds numbers corresponding to outward and inward radial flows, respectively. Axisymmetric and non-axisymmetric disturbances are considered. In the particular case of no axial flow, the Couette flow is stabilized by an inward, or a strong outward, radial flow, but destabilized by a weak outward radial flow. Non-axisymmetric disturbances lead to instability for some negative values of μ=ω2/ω1. Bifurcation diagrams for combined radial and axial flows are more complicated. For particular values of the parameters of the problem, the Couette flow has regions of stabilization and destabilization in the parameter space. Computational results are compared with experimental data.
This paper performs linear stability analysis of base flow velocity profiles for laminar and turbulent water-hammer flows. These base flow velocity profiles are determined analytically, where the transient is generated by an instantaneous reduction in flow rate at the downstream end of a simple pipe system. The presence of inflection points in the base flow velocity profile and the large velocity gradient near the pipe wall are the sources of flow instability. The main parameters that govern the stability behavior of transient flows are the Reynolds number and dimensionless timescale. The stability of the base flow velocity profiles with respect to axisymmetric and asymmetric modes is studied and its results are plotted in the Reynolds number/timescale parameter space. It is found that the asymmetric mode with azimuthal wave number 1 is the least stable. In addition, the results indicate that the decrease of the velocity gradient at the inflection point with time is a stabilizing mechanism whereas the migration of the inflection point from the pipe wall with time is a destabilizing mechanism. Moreover, it is shown that a higher reduction in flow rate, which results in a larger velocity gradient at the inflection point, promotes flow instability. Furthermore, it is found that the stability results of the laminar and the turbulent velocity profiles are consistent with published experimental data and successfully explain controversial conclusions in the literature. The consistency between stability analysis and experiments provide further confirmation that (1) water-hammer flows can become unstable; (2) the instability is asymmetric; (3) instabilities develop in a short (water-hammer) timescale; and (4) the Reynolds number and the wave timescale are important in the characterization of the stability of water-hammer flows. Physically, flow instabilities change the structure and strength of the turbulence in a pipe, result in strong flow asymmetry, and induce significant fluctuations in wall shear stress. These effects of flow instability are not represented in existing water-hammer models.
The bottom friction and the limited vertical extent of the water depth play a significant role in the dynamics of shallow wakes. These effects along with the effect of the strength of the shear layer define the wake parameter $S$. A nonlinear model, based on a second-order explicit finite volume solution of the depth-averaged shallow water equation in which the fluxes are obtained from the solution of the Bhatnagar–Gross–Krook (BGK) Boltzmann equation, is developed and applied to shallow wake flows for which laboratory data are available. The velocity profiles, size of the recirculating wake, oscillation frequency, and wake centreline velocity are studied. The computed and measured results are in reasonable agreement for the vortex street (VS) and unsteady bubble (UB) regimes, but not for the steady bubble (SB). The computed length of the recirculation region is about 60% shorter than the measured value when $S$ belongs to the SB regime. As a result, the stability investigation performed in this paper is restricted to $S$ values away from the transition between SB and UB. Linear analysis of the VS time-averaged velocity profiles reveals a region of absolute instability in the vicinity of the cylinder associated with large velocity deficit, followed by a region of convective instability, which is in turn followed by a stable region. The frequency obtained from Koch's criterion is in good agreement with the shedding frequency of the fully developed VS. However, this analysis does not reveal the mechanism that sets the global shedding frequency of the VS regime because the basic state is obtained from the VS regime itself. The mechanism responsible for VS shedding is sought by investigating the stability behaviour of velocity profiles in the UB regime as $S$ is decreased towards the critical value which defines the transition from the UB to the VS. The results show that the near wake consists of a region of absolute instability sandwiched between two convectively unstable regions. The frequency of the VS appears to be predicted well by the selection criteria given in Pier & Huerre (2001) and Pier (2002), suggesting that the ‘wave-maker’ mechanism proposed in Pier & Huerre (2001) in the context of deep wakes remains valid for shallow wakes. The amplitude spectra produced by the nonlinear model are characterized by a narrow band of large-amplitude frequencies and a wide band of small-amplitude frequencies. Weakly nonlinear analysis indicates that the small amplitude frequencies are due to secondary instabilities. Both the UB and VS regimes are found to be insensitive to random forcing at the inflow boundary. The insensitivity to random noise is consistent with the linear results which show that the UB and VS flows contain regions of absolute instabilities in the near wake where the velocity deficit is large.