Simon Williams

Dr. Simon Williams


Research Focus & Metrics

Academic Career Length

7Years (2020-Present)

(Calculated once Scilit publication data is synced: current year − year of first publication + 1)

Representative Publications

View All Publications
7 October 2021 in Cancers
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
PDF file
SWSimon Williams
Simon Williams
HHHugo Layard Horsfall
Hugo Layard Horsfall
JFJonathan P. Funnell
Jonathan P. Funnell
JHJohn G. Hanrahan
John G. Hanrahan
DKDanyal Khan
Danyal Khan
HMHani Marcus
Hani Marcus
Artificial intelligence (AI) platforms have the potential to cause a paradigm shift in brain tumour surgery. Brain tumour surgery augmented with AI can result in safer and more effective treatment. In this review article, we explore the current and future role of AI in patients undergoing brain tumour surgery, including aiding diagnosis, optimising the surgical plan, providing support during the operation, and better predicting the prognosis. Finally, we discuss barriers to the successful clinical implementation, the ethical concerns, and we provide our perspective on how the field could be advanced.

22 September 2022 in Annals of Surgery
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
BVBaptiste Vasey
Baptiste Vasey
KLKaroline A.N. Lippert
Karoline A.N. Lippert
DKDanyal Khan
Danyal Khan
MIMudathir Ibrahim
Mudathir Ibrahim
CKChan Hee Koh
Chan Hee Koh
PMPeter McCulloch
Peter McCulloch
Objective: A scoping review of the literature was conducted to identify intraoperative AI applications for robotic surgery under development and categorise them by 1) purpose of the applications, 2) level of autonomy, 3) stage of development, and 4) type of measured outcome. Background: In robotic surgery, artificial intelligence (AI) based applications have the potential to disrupt a field so far based on a master-slave paradigm. However, there is no available overview about this technology’s current stage of development and level of autonomy. Methods: MEDLINE and EMBASE were searched between January 1st 2010 and May 21st 2022. Abstract screening, full text review and data extraction were performed independently by two reviewers. Level of autonomy was defined according to the Yang et al classification and stage of development according to the IDEAL framework. Results: 129 studies were included in the review. 97 studies (75%) described applications providing Robot Assistance (autonomy level 1), 30 studies (23%) application enabling Task Autonomy (autonomy level 2), and two studies (2%) application achieving Conditional autonomy (autonomy level 3). All studies were at IDEAL stage 0 and no clinical investigations on humans were found. 116 (90%) conducted in silico or ex-vivo experiments on inorganic material, 9 (7%) ex-vivo experiments on organic material, and 4 (3%) performed in vivo experiments in porcine models. Conclusion: Clinical evaluation of intraoperative AI applications for robotic surgery is still in its infancy and most applications have a low level of autonomy. With increasing levels of autonomy, the evaluation focus seems to shift from AI-specific metrics to process outcomes, although common standards are needed to allow comparison between systems.

24 May 2022 in World Neurosurgery
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
SWSimon Williams
Simon Williams
HHHugo Layard Horsfall
Hugo Layard Horsfall
JFJonathan P. Funnell
Jonathan P. Funnell
JHJohn G. Hanrahan
John G. Hanrahan
ASAndreas T. Schaefer
Andreas T. Schaefer
HMHani Marcus
Hani Marcus
Invasive brain-computer interfaces (BCIs) require neurosurgical implantation, which confers a range of risks. Despite this situation, no studies have assessed the acceptability of invasive BCIs among the neurosurgical team. This study aims to establish baseline knowledge of BCIs within the neurosurgical team and identify attitudes toward different applications of invasive BCI. A 2-stage cross-sectional international survey of the neurosurgical team (neurosurgeons, anesthetists, and operating room nurses) was conducted. Results from the first, qualitative, survey were used to guide the second-stage quantitative survey, which assessed acceptability of invasive BCI applications. Five-part Likert scales were used to collect quantitative data. Surveys were distributed internationally via social media and collaborators. A total of 108 qualitative responses were collected. Themes included the promise of BCIs positively affecting disease targets, concerns regarding stability, and an overall positive emotional reaction to BCI technology. The quantitative survey generated 538 responses from 32 countries. Baseline knowledge of BCI technology was poor, with 9% claiming to have a good or expert knowledge of BCIs. Acceptability of invasive BCI for rehabilitative purposes was >80%. Invasive BCI for augmentation in healthy populations divided opinion. The neurosurgical team's view of the acceptability of invasive BCI was divided across a range of indications. Some applications (e.g., stroke rehabilitation) were viewed as more appropriate than other applications (e.g., augmentation for military use). This range in views highlights the need for stakeholder consultation on acceptable use cases along with regulation and guidance to govern initial BCI implantations if patients are to realize the potential benefits.

30 October 2024 in Annals of Surgery
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
SWSimon Williams
Simon Williams
JZJinfan Zhou
Jinfan Zhou
WMWilliam R. Frcs Muirhead
William R. Frcs Muirhead
DKDanyal Khan
Danyal Khan
CKChan Hee Mrcs Koh
Chan Hee Mrcs Koh
HMHani Marcus
Hani Marcus
Objective: To compare the ability of a deep-learning platform (the MACSSwin-T model) with health care professionals in detecting cerebral aneurysms from operative videos. Secondly, we aimed to compare health care professionals' ability to detect cerebral aneurysms with and without artificial intelligence (AI) assistance. Background: Modern microscopic surgery enables the capture of operative video data on an unforeseen scale. Advances in computer vision, a branch of AI, have enabled automated analysis of operative video. These advances are likely to benefit clinicians, health care systems, and patients alike, yet such benefits are yet to be realized. Methods: In a cross-sectional comparative study, neurosurgeons, anesthetists, and operating room nurses, all at varying stages of training and experience, reviewed still frames of aneurysm clipping operations and labeled frames as “aneurysm not in frame” or “aneurysm in frame.” Frames then underwent analysis by the AI platform. A second round of data collection was performed, whereby the neurosurgical team had AI assistance. The accuracy of aneurysm detection was calculated for human-only, AI-only, and AI-assisted human groups. Results: A total of 5154 individual frame reviews were collated from 338 health care professionals. Health care professionals correctly labeled 70% of frames without AI assistance, compared with 78% with AI assistance (odds ratio: 1.77, P < 0.001). Neurosurgical Attendings showed the greatest improvement, from 77% to 92% correct predictions with AI assistance (odds ratio: 4.24, P = 0.003). Conclusions: AI-assisted human performance surpassed both human and AI alone. Notably, across health care professionals surveyed, frame accuracy improved across all subspecialties and experience levels, particularly among the most experienced health care professionals. These results challenge the prevailing notion that AI primarily benefits junior clinicians, highlighting its crucial role throughout the surgical hierarchy as an essential component of modern surgical practice.

2 February 2024 in British Journal Of Neurosurgery
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
SWSimon Williams
Simon Williams
JSJoachim Starup-Hansen
Joachim Starup-Hansen
JFJonathan P. Funnell
Jonathan P. Funnell
JHJohn Gerrard Hanrahan
John Gerrard Hanrahan
AVAlexandra Valetopoulou
Alexandra Valetopoulou
HMHani J. Marcus
Hani J. Marcus
This study aimed to compare the performance of ChatGPT, a large language model (LLM), with human neurosurgical applicants in a neurosurgical national selection interview, to assess the potential of artificial intelligence (AI) and LLMs in healthcare and provide insights into their integration into the field. In a prospective comparative study, a set of neurosurgical national selection-style interview questions were asked to eight human participants and ChatGPT in an online interview. All participants were doctors currently practicing in the UK who had applied for a neurosurgical National Training Number. Interviews were recorded, anonymised, and scored by three neurosurgical consultants with experience as interviewers for national selection. Answers provided by ChatGPT were used as a template for a virtual interview. Interview transcripts were subsequently scored by neurosurgical consultants using criteria utilised in real national selection interviews. Overall interview score and subdomain scores were compared between human participants and ChatGPT. For overall score, ChatGPT fell behind six human competitors and did not achieve a mean score higher than any individuals who achieved training positions. Several factors, including factual inaccuracies and deviations from expected structure and style may have contributed to ChatGPT's underperformance. LLMs such as ChatGPT have huge potential for integration in healthcare. However, this study emphasises the need for further development to address limitations and challenges. While LLMs have not surpassed human performance yet, collaboration between humans and AI systems holds promise for the future of healthcare.

21 November 2025 in npj Digital Medicine
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
SWSimon Williams
Simon Williams
DKDanyal Z. Khan
Danyal Z. Khan
SBSophia Bano
Sophia Bano
ABAnn Blandford
Ann Blandford
MCMatthew J. Clarkson
Matthew J. Clarkson
HMHani J. Marcus
Hani J. Marcus
Two recent studies in surgical AI video analysis show divergent outcomes based on user expertise and AI explainability. While both demonstrate improved accuracy with AI-assistance, differences in trust and transparency critically shaped impact. This commentary explores human-computer interaction factors such as trust, usability, and explainability, and argues for structured evaluation frameworks to ensure effective, safe integration of AI into surgical practice.