Purpose of Review: This review aims to evaluate and discuss the current advances in the measurement and assessment of the noise generated by unconventional aircraft, such as unmanned aircraft systems (UAS) and urban air mobility (UAM) vehicles. Building upon the findings of this review, research gaps are identified, and further work is proposed to enhance existing and emerging methods for the appropriate noise management of these advanced air mobility (AAM) technologies. Recent Findings: Noise has been highlighted as one of the key concerns for the wider deployment of UAS and UAM operations. This is suggested to be due to having acoustic signatures with sound characteristics commonly associated with noise annoyance, such as ‘sharpness’ (the perceived proportion of high-pitched sonic energy) and ‘tonality’ (the perceptual prominence of concentrated sonic energy at discrete frequencies). These types of ‘psychoacoustic features’ are thought to be connected with observations of increased noise annoyance for AAM, compared with conventional aircraft and road vehicles, at the same level of sound exposure. Summary: In the last few years, there has been a growing body of research on UAS and UAM noise. Research has focused on a comprehensive understanding of the sound sources of these unconventional aircraft under a wide range of operating and operational conditions. Based on gathered evidence, measurement protocols for both laboratory and field studies are very advanced for the acoustic characterisation of UAS in terms of sound level, frequency and directivity. Looking at the human response to UAS and UAM noise, loudness has been consistently reported as the main contributor to noise annoyance, with second-order contributions from other psychoacoustic features, such as sharpness, tonality and ‘amplitude modulation’ (fluctuations in loudness over time), varying among studies. Noise targets for UAS certification have been derived from existing regulations for conventional aircraft and rotorcraft, but might not account for the usually reported annoyance offset between UAS/UAM and conventional vehicles. Key research gaps identified include the lack of studies focusing on multiple events, and deeper understanding of the influence that personal or contextual factors may have on responses, which will be important for the development of robust methods for the assessment and minimisation of community noise annoyance due to the operation of these unconventional aircraft. Graphical
Potential opportunities for unmanned aircraft systems (UAS) to offer societal benefits are accompanied by noise impact risks. Accordingly, it is important to develop greater understanding of perception and response to UAS sound. A laboratory listening experiment was undertaken to address this aim by investigating psychoacoustics of UAS sound exposure. The experiment incorporated contextual auditory and soundscape factors by embedding spatially-rendered UAS sounds within urban acoustic environments. The UAS covered varying aircraft designs, operating modes and numbers of flights. The experiment was focussed on determining noticeability and noise annoyance. The results indicate that annoyance responses were influenced by UAS type, operational mode, sound characteristics, quantities of flights, and the ambient acoustic environments in which UAS events occurred. Annoyance also appeared to have associations with personal attitude towards advanced air mobility technology, and with classification of residence area. Noticeability appeared to be influenced by UAS type, operating mode, loudness and ambient environment.
The potential opportunities for unmanned aerial vehicles (UAVs) to offer wide societal benefits are accompanied by risks of introducing novel sources of community noise impact. Accordingly, it is important to develop a greater understanding of the subjective perception and response to UAV sound. Suitable evidence-based strategies for managing the potential risks to public health and wellbeing can then be devised in the form of flight path optimisation tools, to support initial technology deployment efforts. The ‘REFMAP’ project aims to develop these tools, which will include a component enabling noise constraints to be considered. In support of this objective, a laboratory listening experiment has been undertaken to study psychoacoustic aspects of UAV sound exposure. The experiment design incorporated influences of contextual auditory and soundscape factors, by embedding spatially rendered UAV sound events within ambisonic recordings of urban acoustic environments. The UAV renderings comprised varying flight operations and numbers of flight events. The experiment was focussed on determining both perceptual noticeability and affective responses to UAV sound, including noise annoyance. Initial results from the experimental data analysis are discussed, in the context of future planned work within the REFMAP research project.