Propeller design is a comprehensive task in finding the best trade-off between competing objectives and constraints. It requires a multi-disciplinary evaluation of the propeller performance based on various input parameters. Thus optimisation algorithm applied to this type of problem require consideration of the problem to solve. The purpose of this paper is hence the improvement of commonly used population-based algorithms (NSGA-II and PSO) towards the application of marine propeller design. The extension to three algorithms are outlined utilising meta models, adapted constraints and modified constraints handling. The proposed algorithms are applied on a real-life marine propeller example. Results of 13 optimisations are compared in terms of optimisation convergence, constraints compliance and Pareto optimality and show advantageous performance of the developed cavitation constraints and the meta-model extended NSGA-II.
The use of automated optimisation in engineering applications is emerging. In particular, nature inspired algorithms are frequently used because of their variability and robust application in constraints and multi-objective optimisation problems. The purpose of this paper is the comparison of four different algorithms and several optimisation strategies on a set of seven test propellers in realistic industrial design setting. The propellers are picked from real commercial projects and the manual final designs were delivered to customers. The different approaches are evaluated and final results of the automated optimisation toolbox are compared with designs generated in a manual design process. We identify a two-stage optimisation for marine propellers, where the geometry is first modified by parametrised geometry distribution curves to gather knowledge of the test case. Here we vary the optimisation strategy in terms of applied algorithms, constraints and objectives. A second supporting optimisation aims to improve the design by locally changing the geometry, based on the results of the first optimisation. The optimisation algorithms and strategies yield propeller designs that are comparable to the manually designed propeller blade geometries, thus being suitable as robust and advanced design support tools. The supporting optimisation, with local modification of the blade geometry and the proposed cavity shape constraints, features particular good performance in modifying cavitation on the blade and is, with the AS NSGA-II (adaptive surrogate-assisted NSGA-II), superior in lead time.