Objective: To investigate whether bias in clinical history affects accuracy of electrocardiograph (ECG) interpretation among doctors working in emergency departments.Design and setting: Observational study conducted at four teaching hospitals in Sydney from May to September 2011.Participants: Emergency registrars and physicians (senior doctors), and interns, resident medical officers and senior resident medical officers (junior doctors).Intervention: Participants interpreted 30 ECGs ...
Teaching the complex interactions between hosts and pathogens is a fundamental yet educationally challenging aspect of life science and healthcare education. The intricate mechanisms of the immune system can pose significant barriers to students’ understanding of infectious disease diagnosis and treatment. To address this, we used a web-based digital whiteboard platform to design a card-based competitive game called Micro-Immune Battles, aimed at more actively engaging students with microbiology and immunology to better develop their knowledge and underlying concepts. The game facilitates learning through a series of infectious disease scenarios, providing student teams with ‘immune system response cards’ that represent various immune elements. Working in teams, learners must construct sequential card cascades that correctly correspond to the specified pathogen in the scenario. This reinforces the temporal progression of immune responses whilst encouraging the application of theoretical knowledge to practical cases. Scoring is determined by the accuracy and speed of card placements, incentivizing rapid yet correct synthesis of knowledge. Points are deducted for incorrect placements, introducing an element of calculated risk-taking and critical reasoning. Analysis showed statistically significant improvements in microbiology and immunology knowledge after playing the game.
Background: Clinical reasoning is reliant on students having acquired a strong foundation in the basic sciences. However, there remains uncertainty regarding whether medical students are maintaining this knowledge over the span of their degrees. Therefore, this project aimed to assess long‐term retention of basic science knowledge within a cohort of students from an undergraduate medical school in the United Kingdom (UK). Methods: This longitudinal study followed a cohort of students, from their first to final year. In their final year, participants sat a bespoke formative basic science knowledge assessment that utilised 46 single‐best‐answer questions. To examine for long‐term attainment differences, these scores were compared with those achieved in first‐year assessments. Results: Of the eligible students, 40% partook in the study ( n = 22). Comparing assessment scores highlighted an enhancement in overall basic science knowledge between first and final year ( p < 0.01). Although most basic science domains remained unchanged between both time points, anatomy and physiology scores increased ( p = 0.03 and p = 0.02, respectively), whereas biochemistry scores were the only ones to decrease ( p = 0.02). Discussion: This project provides insight into how well students are retaining the basic sciences during their studies. Underperforming science domains were identified, alongside pedagogical explanations for their individual shortcomings; for instance, students' perceived relevance of a domain is seen as a driver for its retention. Subsequently, a group of recommendations were derived to reinforce the most affected domains. The inclusion of more questions on the underperforming sciences, in clinically focussed assessments, is one such suggestion.
Driven by demand for high standards in university education, efforts have been made in the UK to address the perceived imbalance between teaching and research. However, teaching is still perceived by many as having less credibility and is attributed less importance. The purpose of our research was to explore how distinct types of academic job profiles (‘research’ or ‘education’ focused, or ‘balanced’) impact on biomedical scientists' perceptions of the lecturer role. Specifically, we investigated the experiences of biomedical scientists in ‘post‐1990’ medical schools, which are known for their commitment to excellence in both research and education. We conducted 22 face‐to‐face, semi‐structured interviews with biomedical scientists in five schools. Focusing on experiences of work, the interviews covered: ‘motivations’, ‘role expectations’, ‘teaching’, ‘research’ and ‘career’. The recorded qualitative data were transcribed and then analysed thematically. Our results, offering an insight into the working lives of biomedical scientists in medical education, suggest that in settings with a dual emphasis on education and research, individuals on ‘balanced’ contracts can experience a strong pull between research and teaching. In addition to posing significant challenges with respect to workload management, this can impact profoundly on professional identity. In contrast to the balanced role, ‘research’ or ‘education’ focused roles appear to have clearer requirements, leading to higher employee satisfaction. We conclude that to assist the educational mission of Higher Education, attention should be paid to balanced contracts, to (a) ensure employee support, (b) mitigate against negative perceptions of teaching, and ultimately, (c) guard against staff attrition.
Background Physician associates (PAs) are medical associate professionals who work under the supervision of a doctor within multi-disciplinary teams. Though newly qualified PAs are expected to perform at the same level as newly qualified doctors, no studies have compared the level of medical knowledge upon graduation. The aim of this analysis was to determine the knowledge of PAs in comparison to medical students and Foundation Year 1 (FY1) doctors in the UK. Methods We undertook a retrospective analysis of assessment data from identical medical knowledge progress tests taken by PA students, medical students, and FY1 doctors. Student performance data were collated for each of the 88 identical items, from all cohorts, across all stages of the PA and medical programmes, as well as all cohorts of FY1 doctors sitting the exam. Results Analysis showed that PA student performance was comparable to medical students and FY1 doctors. At Stage 1 end, PA student mean performance was consistent with Stage 3 medicine (36.35%, 34.81%, respectively), whereas at Stage 2 end, PA performance was consistent with Stage 4 medicine (51.63%, 49.92%, respectively). Growth between Stage 1 and 2 PA, and Stage 3 and 4 medicine was almost identical. Significantly, many Stage 2 PA students met or exceeded Stage 5 medicine and FY1 performance upon graduation. Conclusions This is the first UK analysis that directly compares PA medical knowledge to medical students and FY1 doctors, provides evidence of the standard of PA knowledge, and reassurance that graduates are achieving the required standard.
Teaching the complex interactions between hosts and pathogens is a fundamental yet educationally challenging aspect of life science and healthcare education. The intricate mechanisms of the immune system can pose significant barriers to students’ understanding of infectious disease diagnosis and treatment. To address this, we used a web-based digital whiteboard platform to design a card-based competitive game called Micro-Immune Battles, aimed at more actively engaging students with microbiology and immunology to better develop their knowledge and underlying concepts. The game facilitates learning through a series of infectious disease scenarios, providing student teams with "immune system response cards" that represent various immune elements. Working in teams, learners must construct sequential card cascades that correctly correspond to the specified pathogen in the scenario. This reinforces the temporal progression of immune responses, whilst encouraging the application of theoretical knowledge to practical cases. Scoring is determined by the accuracy and speed of card placements, incentivising rapid yet correct synthesis of knowledge. Points are deducted for incorrect placements, introducing an element of calculated risk-taking and critical reasoning. Analysis showed statistically significant improvements in microbiology and immunology knowledge after playing the game.