Healthcare-associated infections are a serious burden globally. Few qualitative studies have explored healthcare workers’ knowledge, attitudes and practices of hand hygiene. Prior to the implementation of the World Health Organization’s Hand Hygiene Improvement Strategy at Faranah Regional Hospital in the Upper Region of Guinea in December 2018, we conducted a qualitative baseline assessment of knowledge, attitudes and practices of hand hygiene among healthcare workers to guide future hand hygiene interventions. The qualitative study consisted of direct observations, In-Depth Interviews (IDIs) and Focus Group Discussions (FGDs). We found that the 2013–16 Ebola outbreak had had a pivotal impact on healthcare workers’ knowledge, attitudes and practices. The severity of the disease and the training provided for infection control were responsible for their knowledge acquisition and adoption of good attitudes and practices. However, negligence, resulting in poor hand hygiene practices, rose after the outbreak, once the “cue of fear” that had motivated workers for their own self-protection had waned. Our results suggest that local capacity building through training and availability of hand hygiene materials would be a sustainable approach to enhance hand hygiene culture at the hospital. Our study suggests that there is a need for a high and long-term commitment of authorities and healthcare workers at all levels for a sustainable hand hygiene culture.
17 February 2022 in Antimicrobial Resistance & Infection Control
Introduction: The most frequent adverse events in healthcare are healthcare-associated infections, whose burden is highest in resource-limited settings. In addition, low resource settings often lack Hand Hygiene (HH) knowledge and reliable supply to disinfectant, a necessity emphasized by the past West African Ebola Epidemic and the ongoing COVID-19 pandemic. PASQUALE aims to increase patient safety by introducing the WHO multimodal HH strategy in the University Hospital Bouaké, Côte d’Ivoire. Methods: Assessment of HH knowledge, perception and compliance was performed 12 months before, right after the intervention and at a ten months interval using questionnaires for knowledge and perception and direct observation for compliance. The intervention consisted of a HH training and the introduction of local production of alcohol-based hand-rub. In the absence of a control group, the effectiveness of the intervention was assessed by a before-and-after study. Results: Baseline knowledge score was 14/25, increased significantly to 17/25 (p < 0.001) upon first and decreased to 13/25 in second follow-up. Compliance showed a significant increase from 12.7% to 36.8% (p < 0.001) in first and remained at 36.4% in second follow-up. Alcohol-based hand-rub production and consumption almost doubled after first confirmed COVID-19 case in Côte d’Ivoire. Conclusion: The WHO HH improvement strategy is an effective and pandemic-adaptable method to increase long-term HH compliance. This study emphasizes that the implementation of the strategy to build a robust system is of utmost importance.
The World Health Organization Multimodal Hand Hygiene Improvement Strategy aims at reducing healthcare-associated infections; however, evidence of applicability and effectiveness at the primary care level is scarce, especially in healthcare centers in resource-limited settings. The objectives of this study were to improve hand hygiene knowledge and compliance at two healthcare centers in the region of Faranah, Guinea, to increase the availability of alcohol-based hand rub (ABHR), and to assess the effectiveness of the strategy at the primary care level. Knowledge, perceptions, and compliance were assessed prior to the intervention and compared to those of two follow-up assessments, immediately and 6 months after the intervention. The intervention consisted of training and the supply of ABHR. The monthly consumption of ABHR was monitored. Baseline knowledge increased from a score of 11/25 at baseline to 16/25 at first follow-up; it then decreased to 15/25 at the second follow-up. Compliance showed an increase from 15.6% to 84.4% (P < 0.001) at the first follow-up. At the second follow-up, compliance was lower than at the first follow-up (53.2%, P < 0.001), but still more than two times higher than at baseline (P < 0.001). ABHR consumption averaged 0.77 ml per consultation. The World Health Organization hand hygiene strategy is an appropriate method to improve compliance and knowledge at the primary care level, but needs some adjustment: the inclusion of observation of the correctness of hand hygiene action, as well as training emphasizing the amount of ABHR to use.
There is a growing interest in the implementation of people-centered components within outbreak preparedness and response plans and their resulting governance. Information on this topic still remains scarce, in particular in settings like Guinea, West Africa. We draw from 21 qualitative interviews with healthcare workers in the context of COVID-19 from the Faranah Regional Hospital in Guinea to explore pandemic preparedness and response adherence as well as its corresponding senses of vulnerability and risk, information sources, perceived information reliability, associated rumors and previous outbreak experiences. To achieve a broader analysis, we make use of the “therapeutic landscape” concept which conceives health provision as a process constructed through practices, beliefs and experiences. A theme articulated across interviews was an overabundance of information, which caused confusion mainly due to rumors and a lack of trust in the country’s health system. Initial fear gradually diminished due to the disease’s low mortality rate in the country. HCWs described preparedness enforcement in the city of Faranah that started strong but lightened overtime. This waning of enforcement marked a difference between the city and the hospital. HCWs appraised the first positive case declaration in the city as the most significant moment, followed by a strong community reaction hindering the pandemic governance. We conclude that preparedness and response plans need to better socially situate their interventions and devote more structural efforts into incorporating the social landscapes of a disease and an outbreak. Incorporation of these social landscapes facilitates understanding of operational barriers to their people-centered approaches. Responses should therefore comprehend 1) hospitals as applying different pandemic understandings transcending biomedical and scientific orders and 2) HCWs as portraying shifting pre-existing identities leading to marked in-/out-group distinctions directly influencing healthcare, risk perception as well as information and rumors management.
This study explores the concept of the domestic within the One Health approach by examining how human-animal-environment relations shape health and survival in everyday life. Drawing on ethnographic research conducted in the Democratic Republic of the Congo, Nigeria, and Côte d'Ivoire during the rainy and dry seasons of 2022-2023, we explore how the domestic is continually produced through multispecies relationality of care, ecology, and biopolitics. Instead of treating the household as a fixed surveillance unit, we trace how domesticity extends into abattoirs, courtyards, and neighbourhoods - sites where feeding, healing, killing, and cohabiting connect human and non-human lives under ecological change, economic precarity, and health surveillance. These entanglements reveal how caring relations, ecological adaptation, and governance intersect in ways that challenge One Health's conventional boundaries between human, animal, and environmental domains. This study demonstrates how health emerges through ongoing relatedness and interdependence, by conceptualising domesticity as a dynamic terrain of multispecies dwelling. This relational perspective attunes One Health to a more inclusive understanding of multispecies well-being among increasing climatic pressures.
There is a growing interest in the implementation of people-centered components within outbreak preparedness and response plans and their resulting governance. Information on this topic still remains scarce, particularly in settings such as Guinea in West Africa. In the context of COVID-19, we conducted 21 qualitative interviews with healthcare workers (HCWs) from the Faranah Regional Hospital in Guinea to explore pandemic preparedness and response adherence. We also analyzed corresponding senses of vulnerability and risk, information sources, perceived information reliability, associated rumors and previous outbreak experiences. To achieve a broader analysis, we employed the “therapeutic landscape” concept, which conceives health provision as a process constructed through practices, beliefs and experiences. A recurring theme across the interviews was the abundance of information, which caused confusion mainly due to rumors and a lack of trust in the country’s health system. Initial fear gradually diminished due to the disease’s low mortality rate in the country. HCWs described preparedness enforcement in the city of Faranah that started strongly but gradually relaxed over time. This waning of enforcement marked a difference between the city and the hospital. HCWs appraised the first positive case declaration in the city to be the most significant moment, followed by a strong community reaction hindering the pandemic governance. We conclude that preparedness and response plans must better situate their interventions socially and devote more structural efforts to incorporating the social landscapes of diseases and outbreaks. Incorporating these social landscapes facilitates an understanding of the operational barriers to people-centered approaches. It also serves as an indicator for strengthening infodemic detection and management. Responses should therefore consider 1) hospitals applying different pandemic understandings that transcend biomedical and scientific orders, and 2) HCWs as portraying shifting pre-existing identities leading to marked in-/out-group distinctions, which directly influence healthcare, risk perception, and information and rumor management.