Orchids are one of the most diverse flowering plant families, yet possibly maintain the smallest number of the nucleotide-binding site-leucine-rich repeat (NBS-LRR) type plant resistance (R) genes among the angiosperms. In this study, a genome-wide search in four orchid taxa identified 186 NBS-LRR genes. Furthermore, 214 NBS-LRR genes were identified from seven orchid transcriptomes. A phylogenetic analysis recovered 30 ancestral lineages (29 CNL and one RNL), far fewer than other angiosperm families. From the genetics aspect, the relatively low number of ancestral R genes is unlikely to explain the low number of R genes in orchids alone, as historical gene loss and scarce gene duplication has continuously occurred, which also contributes to the low number of R genes. Due to recent sharp expansions, Phalaenopsis equestris and Dendrobium catenatum having 52 and 115 genes, respectively, and exhibited an “early shrinking to recent expanding” evolutionary pattern, while Gastrodia elata and Apostasia shenzhenica both exhibit a “consistently shrinking” evolutionary pattern and have retained only five and 14 NBS-LRR genes, respectively. RNL genes remain in extremely low numbers with only one or two copies per genome. Notably, all of the orchid RNL genes belong to the ADR1 lineage. A separate lineage, NRG1, was entirely absent and was likely lost in the common ancestor of all monocots. All of the TNL genes were absent as well, coincident with the RNL NRG1 lineage, which supports the previously proposed notion that a potential functional association between the TNL and RNL NRG1 genes.

Nucleotide-binding site (NBS)-type disease resistance genes (R genes) play key roles in plant immune responses and have co-evolved with pathogens over the course of plant lifecycles. Comparative genomic studies tracing the dynamic evolution of NBS-encoding genes have been conducted using many important plant lineages. However, studies on Sapindaceae species have not been performed. In this study, a discrepant number of NBS-encoding genes were identified in the genomes of Xanthoceras sorbifolium (180), Dinnocarpus longan (568), and Acer yangbiense (252). These genes were unevenly distributed and usually clustered as tandem arrays on chromosomes, with few existed as singletons. The phylogenetic analysis revealed that NBS-encoding genes formed three monophyletic clades, RPW8-NBS-LRR (RNL), TIR-NBS-LRR (TNL), and CC-NBS-LRR (CNL), which were distinguished by amino acid motifs. The NBS-encoding genes of the X. sorbifolium, D. longan, and A. yangbiense genomes were derived from 181 ancestral genes (three RNL, 23 TNL, and 155 CNL), which exhibited dynamic and distinct evolutionary patterns due to independent gene duplication/loss events. Specifically, X. sorbifolium exhibited a “first expansion and then contraction” evolutionary pattern, while A. yangbiense and D. longan exhibited a “first expansion followed by contraction and further expansion” evolutionary pattern. However, further expansion in D. longan was stronger than in A. yangbiense after divergence, suggesting that D. longan gained more genes in response to various pathogens. Additionally, the ancient and recent expansion of CNL genes generated the dominance of this subclass in terms of gene numbers, while the low copy number status of RNL genes was attributed to their conserved functions.

Tropaeolum majus (nasturtium) is an important ornamental and medicinal plant due to its colorful flowers, shield-shaped leaves, and richness in mineral elements and bioactive compounds. However, the key genes related to these important biological traits, as well as their expression patterns and functions, remain obscure. In this study, to choose appropriate reference genes for quantitative real-time reverse transcription polymerase chain reaction (qRT-PCR) analysis, we screened 14 candidate genes from the transcriptome of T. majus and evaluated their expression stability. Through evaluation with four commonly used algorithms (geNorm, NormFinder, BestKeeper, and RefFinder), EXP1, EXP2, and TUB6 were found to be the most stably expressed genes among different organs, while EXP1 combined with CYP2 was identified as the optimal reference gene combination for seeds at different development stages. For all the tested samples, EXP1, EXP2, CYP2, and ACT2 were the most suitable reference genes. Moreover, the target gene KCS11 involved in very-long-chain fatty acid biosynthesis was employed to confirm the most and least stable reference genes in different organs, seeds at different development stages, and all the tested samples. The expression profiles of KCS11 were similar, with minor differences based on the analysis of different stable reference genes (either alone or in combination), while the expression profiles were diverse and the relative expression level was overestimated when using the least stable ones. These results suggest that the appropriate selection of reference genes is critical for the normalization of gene expression. Furthermore, the reference genes screened in this study will greatly improve the accuracy of the qRT-PCR quantification of candidate genes involved in the many biological characteristics of nasturtium.