Elaine Ruth Carnegie

Dr. Elaine Ruth Carnegie

orcid

Research Focus & Metrics

Academic Career Length

17Years (2010-Present)

(Calculated once Scilit publication data is synced: current year − year of first publication + 1)

Representative Publications

View All Publications
ECElaine Ruth Carnegie
Elaine Ruth Carnegie
GIGreig Inglis
Greig Inglis
ATAnnie Taylor
Annie Taylor
ABAnna Bak-Klimek
Anna Bak-Klimek
OOOgochukwu Okoye
Ogochukwu Okoye
Over the last three decades, researchers have investigated population density and health outcomes at differing scale. There has not been a systematic review conducted in order to synthesise this evidence. Following the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews (PRISMA) guidelines, we systematically reviewed quantitative evidence published since 1990 on population density and non-communicable disease (NCD) within Westernised countries. Fifty-four studies met the inclusion criteria and were evaluated utilising a quality assessment tool for ecological studies. High population density appears to be associated with higher mortality rates of a range of cancers, cardiovascular disease and COPD, and a higher incidence of a range of cancers, asthma and club foot. In contrast, diabetes incidence was found to be associated with low population density. High and low population density are therefore risk markers for a range of NCDs, indicating that there are unidentified factors and mechanisms underlying aetiology. On closer examination, our synthesis revealed important and complex relationships between population density, the built environment, the nature of greenspace and man-made exposures. In light of increasing rates of morbidity and mortality, future research is required to investigate these associations in order to establish causative agents for each NCD.

23 January 2017 in Health Education Journal
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
ECElaine Ruth Carnegie
Elaine Ruth Carnegie
AWAnne Whittaker
Anne Whittaker
CBCarol Gray Brunton
Carol Gray Brunton
RHRhona Hogg
Rhona Hogg
CKCatriona Kennedy
Catriona Kennedy
JPJanette Pow
Janette Pow
Objective: To examine cultural barriers and participant solutions regarding acceptance and uptake of the human papillomavirus (HPV) vaccine from the perspective of Black African, White-Caribbean, Arab, Indian, Bangladeshi and Pakistani young people. Methods: In total, 40 young people from minority ethnic communities in Scotland took part in a qualitative study, involving seven focus groups and four paired interviews, to explore their views and experiences of the HPV vaccine. Using critical discursive psychology, the analysis focused on young people’s accounts of barriers and enablers to information, access and uptake of the HPV vaccination programme. Results: Participants suggested innovative strategies to tackle intergenerational concerns, information design and accessibility, and public health communications across diverse contexts. A cross-cultural community engagement model was developed, embracing diversity and contradiction across different ethnic groups. This included four inter-related strategies: providing targeted and flexible information for young people, vaccine provision across the life-course, intergenerational information and specific cross-cultural communications. Conclusion: This is the first HPV cross-cultural model inductively derived from accounts of young people from different ethnic communities. We recommend public health practitioners and policymakers consider using the processes and strategies within this model to increase dialogue around public engagement, awareness and receptivity towards HPV vaccination.

26 July 2023 in Journal of Public Health in Africa
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
OOOgochukwu Okoye
Ogochukwu Okoye
ECElaine Ruth Carnegie
Elaine Ruth Carnegie
Luca MoraLuca Mora
Luca Mora
Background. Ambient air pollution has persisted in lessendowed communities, resulting in exposure to unhealthy pollutants. Epidemiological studies on air pollution have been mainly quantitative, with a dearth of information on community health risk perception, a key component of risk management.Objectives. The aim of this focus group study was to highlight the health risk perception of ambient air pollution among people residing near a petrochemical industry and to determine their perceptions of the existing control measures and ideas for more effective control.Methods. Participants were purposefully selected based on age, sex, long-term residence near a petroleum refinery, and occupation. Three 90-minute face-to-face focus groups and one individual interview were conducted. The moderator guided discussions using a pre-formed topic guide. Discussions were audio-recorded, transcribed manually, and coded using NVivo software. The data analysis was conducted using reflexive thematic analysis.Results. Six themes were generated: negative perception of the environment; the refinery is to blame; air pollution is seen or smelled; air pollution is associated with health and non-health risks; poor response to air pollution- everyone is to blame and the government is primarily responsible for healthy air quality. The participants were not aware of the extent of air pollution’s health risks. Suggestions for air pollution control included regulating gas flaring, environmental health education, and incentives for community members.Conclusion. Participants perceived that their ambient air was unhealthy. However, concerns about the health risks were shaped by contextual factors. The key barriers to effective mitigation were poor environmental health literacy and political factors.

26 May 2023 in International Journal of Drug Policy
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
ATAnnie Taylor
Annie Taylor
AWAnne Whittaker
Anne Whittaker
ACAmy Chandler
Amy Chandler
ECElaine Ruth Carnegie
Elaine Ruth Carnegie
Drinking alcohol during pregnancy is associated with Foetal Alcohol Spectrum Disorders (FASD), and women who drink at higher levels are more likely to have a baby with FASD. Public health responses focus on population-level approaches to FASD prevention such as promoting abstinence and alcohol brief interventions. Efforts to better understand and respond to 'high risk' drinking during pregnancy have been largely ignored. This meta-ethnography of qualitative research aims to inform this policy and practice agenda. Ten health, social care, and social sciences databases were searched for qualitative studies published since 2000 exploring drinking during pregnancy. Studies that included accounts of women who described themselves, or were diagnosed as, alcohol-dependent during pregnancy, or reported drinking during pregnancy at levels considered by the Word Health Organisation to constitute 'high risk' drinking, were eligible. Noblit and Hare's analytic approach to meta-ethnography was used to synthesise the studies and eMERGe reporting guidance was followed. Nine diverse studies were included. All explored the impact of social norms and relationships, women's knowledge about the risks involved in drinking during pregnancy, the behaviour of women, and the advice they received. Three key themes were identified: drinking is social and relational, knowledge is not enough, and multiple adversities matter. Multiple adversities were interconnected and primarily related to structural inequalities and oppression. The complex needs of women and the wider context in which their drinking occurred were rarely explored or responded to during pregnancy. This meta-ethnography provides a more nuanced understanding of the complex dynamics involved in women's 'high risk' drinking during pregnancy, the contexts in which they drink and their unmet needs. These findings can inform future policy and practice responses to 'high risk' drinking during pregnancy. Further research should explore women's experiences in a UK context and consider how services could meet women's needs.

7 August 2025 in International Journal of Behavioral Medicine
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
CBCarol Gray Brunton
Carol Gray Brunton
ECElaine Ruth Carnegie
Elaine Ruth Carnegie
JPJanette Pow
Janette Pow
ITIrina Todorova
Irina Todorova
DPDafina Petrova
Dafina Petrova
AWAnne Whittaker
Anne Whittaker
Background: Globally, human papillomavirus (HPV) vaccine uptake rates have declined within a wider context of vaccine hesitancy. Gender-neutral vaccine programmes are increasing and recommended for the prevention of cervical, anogenital, and oropharyngeal cancers affecting both women and men. To address the problem of suboptimal HPV uptake rates for boys and men, we aimed to understand young men’s communication needs for HPV messages in a cross-cultural analysis. Methods: Qualitative methods consisting of 14 focus group discussions were conducted with young men (18–26 years) about the HPV vaccine in three countries with varying HPV vaccine implementation policies at the time. A total of 55 participants were included from Scotland (n=14), Spain (n=25), single-gendered programmes, and the USA (n=16), gender-neutral programme. Analysis was informed by reflexive thematic analysis. Findings: Four themes were identified: (1) the ‘Girl vaccine’: primarily seen as a vaccine for girls, despite varying vaccine knowledge and awareness across contexts; (2) vaccine ambivalence: perceptions of men’s HPV risks were low and some vaccine worries were evident from US contexts; (3) altruism: a pervasive theme related to young men’s roles and responsibilities for HPV transmission within relationships; (4) trusted sources: messages from health care providers/authorities were persistently valued but direct opportunities were often absent. Conclusion: Public health messaging to increase HPV vaccination for young men should focus on direct appeal to young men’s health through specific and targeted HPV messages for cancer and sexual health benefits to increase the personal relevance of the vaccine. It should also focus on indirect appeal through incorporating messages about safe sex in relationships and for herd immunity. Healthcare providers and authorities are trusted sources of information and can influence men’s confidence for the HPV vaccine; opportunities for interactions should be optimised.

21 April 2025 in Human Vaccines & Immunotherapeutics
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
ECElaine Ruth Carnegie
Elaine Ruth Carnegie
CGCarol Gray-Brunton
Carol Gray-Brunton
CKCatriona Kennedy
Catriona Kennedy
JPJanette Pow
Janette Pow
DWDiane Willis
Diane Willis
AWAnne Whittaker
Anne Whittaker
The success of vaccination programs relies on acceptance of recommended vaccines by communities and individuals. There is a paucity of evidence regarding how young men with intellectual disabilities actively produce or receive inclusive and accessible HPV information. As part of a larger qualitative study, we explored how young men with mild-moderate intellectual disabilities contend with information on HPV and how they negotiated safer sex prior to the introduction of the Scottish schools-based gender-neutral HPV vaccination program in 2019. Objectives included identifying strategies for reaching young men with intellectual disabilities; identifying modes of communication that enable young men with intellectual disabilities to discuss HPV; exploring knowledge, awareness, relevance, and participant experiences of HPV vaccination; perceived barriers and facilitators toward vaccination behavior; perceptions of publicly available HPV information and formats. Working with institutions of further education to identify participants, 18 young men chose to participate. Three focus group discussions using activity-oriented questions were conducted. Regardless of ability, a series of activities enabled them to explore questions about their knowledge of HPV and any experience of the vaccination program. Communication aids included familiar objects and symbols from daily life breaking down barriers and power inequities. Data were analyzed drawing on critical discourse analysis. Designed and tailored communication interventions were effective in reaching this population group. Adopting a participatory activity-oriented approach and spending significant time looking at pictures and artifacts enabled young men with mild-moderate intellectual disabilities to discuss behavioral risks and consequences of HPV and to identify design factors for accessible health information.