The acquisition and analysis of data in digital forensics raise different data privacy challenges. Many existing works on digital forensic readiness discuss what information should be stored and how to collect relevant data to facilitate investigations. However, the cost of this readiness often directly impacts the privacy of innocent third parties and suspects if the collected information is irrelevant. Approaches that have been suggested for privacy-preserving digital forensics focus on the use of policy, non-cryptography-based, and cryptography-based solutions. Cryptographic techniques have been proposed to address issues of data privacy during data analysis. As the utilization of some of these cryptographic techniques continues to increase, it is important to evaluate their applicability and challenges in relation to digital forensics processes. This study provides digital forensics investigators and researchers with a roadmap to understanding the data privacy challenges in digital forensics and examines the various privacy techniques that can be utilized to tackle these challenges. Specifically, we review the cryptographic techniques applied for privacy protection in digital forensics and categorize them within the context of whether they support trusted third parties, multiple investigators, and multi-keyword searches. We highlight some of the drawbacks of utilizing cryptography-based methods in privacy-preserving digital forensics and suggest potential solutions to the identified shortcomings. In addition, we propose a conceptual privacy-preserving digital forensics (PPDF) model that is based on the use of cryptographic techniques and analyze the model within the context of the above-mentioned factors. An evaluation of the model is provided through a consideration of identified factors that may affect an investigation. Lastly, we provide an analysis of how existing principles for preserving privacy in digital forensics are addressed in our PPDF model. Our evaluation shows that the model aligns with many of the existing privacy principles recommended for privacy protection in digital forensics.
Despite the benefits of the widespread adoption of mobile technologies, older adults continue to face significant security and privacy challenges in their use of mobile devices, due to several factors. This often results in the avoidance of certain security and privacy mechanisms, leaving many older adults vulnerable to digital security challenges and privacy risks. This paper examines 41 peer-reviewed studies to investigate how older adults view and control mobile security and privacy mechanisms, risks, and challenges. We examine the perceptions around mobile security and privacy mechanisms and educational and support strategies. Our findings highlight how closely security and privacy concerns relate to system design and support, and user knowledge. It also emphasizes promising methods such as embedded social learning, tailored training, and policy recommendations to address highlighted issues, allowing developers and policymakers to more effectively instill confidence and facilitate better digital inclusion and mobile security and privacy of older adults.
With the increasing trend of digitization of business processes and personal communication across the globe, digital documents of intrinsic value continue to be created. Whereas the questioned document examination (QDE) field of forensic science deals with the examination of “physical” documents potentially disputed in a court of law, there are no developed approaches for handling questioned digital documents (QDDs). Although techniques that address related problems such as identifying document types and image forensics exist, concrete strategies for analyzing questioned “digital” documents still need to be developed. This paper focuses on developing methods to examine QDDs that are customized from a database, due to the versatile use of customized documents in many areas. As a basis for our approach, we make the case for the need to develop analysis techniques for a digital counterpart of QDE which we term Questioned Digital Document Examination (QDDE). We posit that there is a benefit in considering digital aspects of forensic science disciplines where the questions answered by the discipline are clear, from a digital perspective. The paper describes some of the aspects that can be considered in the domain of question digital document examination. In designing methods for QDDE, we discuss the process of document recreation and describe the feasibility of our recreation process in different scenarios. Our experiments show that an alternative approach of considering digital aspects from a well‐defined physical domain is worthwhile. It also supports the practical application of our approach in examining documents customized from a database.
The increase in digital communications has led to changes in the nature of documents that are often encountered in document examinations. Whereas document examiners use physical and chemical characteristics to authenticate documents and examine hypotheses about the age, origin, alterations, and signatures, digital documents cannot be subjected to such methods. This has led to calls for alternative approaches to digital document examination. In this paper, we present a comparative study that explores the determination of document origin, particularly, the identification of the creator tool type and the applicability of structural-based and machine-learning file type identification methods to this problem. To generate a baseline for the comparison of our methods, we implemented several machine learning algorithms that have most commonly and successfully been used for file type identification. These methods are then applied for tool type identification for digital documents to evaluate their relevance and effectiveness in this case. The paper focuses on the identification of creator tool types for Portable Document Format (PDF) documents due to their prevalence. We present our approach for identifying the tool used to create a document and evaluate our results against baseline results from file type identification. Our result shows that many of the structure-based analysis methods and machine learning algorithms used in file type identification can be extended to tool type identification in forensic digital document examination. The paper provides recommendations for adopting this extension and is the first work to explore the comparison of file type identification methods for creator tool type identification.