This study intends to explore the salience of national identity for young people from the perspective of ‘commitment and loyalty’ to their nation. The uniqueness of this study is that it provides the opportunity to observe the salience of civic, ethnic, and cultural features of national identity in Kazakhstan. This article has examined the importance of national identity theoretically and critically reviewed the literature on this theme. For the case study, a small survey was conducted in order to evaluate the salience of membership to national identity among young students. An academic implication of this research entails further research on the salience of belonging and sense of attachment to national identity among young people in other cosmopolitan cities of Kazakhstan, such as Almaty, Astana, and Atyrau, where the effect of globalisation is more prevalent and the Kazakh customs and traditions less noticeable in order to make a comparative evaluation. In this context, this research will consider the importance of national identity for young individuals by analysing the theories on nations and nationalism, specifically emphasising the relation between individuals and their nations. This will then be complemented by a primary source in the form of a short survey on the subject of national identity, which will be carried out among students of the Kazakh-Turkish International University in Turkestan, Kazakhstan. Subsequently, the findings will be evaluated and discussed to address the research question. Finally, the results of the survey will be summarised in the conclusion.
Bu çeviri, Mihail Yevgeneviç Masson’un Hoca Ahmet Yesevi Türbesi konulu makalesinden oluşmaktadır. Mihail Yevgeneviç Masson, Ahmet Yesevi Türbesine ilişkin yaptığı araştırmasını yazılı kaynaklar ile yerinde gözlemleriyle tamamlamıştır. Çeviride verilen bilgiler, günümüzde bağlantı ve tecrübesi olmayan birçok konuyu da içermekte ve yaptığı araştırmasında tanık olduğu hadiseleri aktarmasından dolayı çalışması daha fazla önem kazanmaktadır. Özellikle Ahmet Yesevi Türbesi etrafında ziyaretçilerin uygulamalarına ilişkin verilen bilgiler dikkat çekicidir. Anahtar Kelimeler: Ahmet Yesevi Türbesi, Yesevi Zikri, Mihail Yevgeneviç Masson.
12 November 2025 in Journal of Religion and Health
This article intends to investigate this issue objectively and honestly without bias from the comparative viewpoint between Islam and Christianity. The methodology of the article is to have a comparative analysis of the concept of salvation in both Islam and Christianity by presenting the similarities and differences. This article utilises passages from the Qur’an and the Gospel as primary sources, which will be complemented with journal articles as a secondary source. The first section looks at the terminology of ‘salvation’ within Islam and Christianity from the viewpoints of sin, repentance and forgiveness, as salvation in both Christianity and Islam means saving from the consequences of sin, and in both religions this involves repentance by humans and forgiveness by God. The second part of this article will examine how Muslims and Christians view Jesus in relation to salvation. This is tied to salvation because the death and resurrection of Jesus is how Christians believe salvation has been accomplished. The final section of this article analyses the God doctrine of Christianity and the God concept of Islam from the comparative perspective with regards to the topic of salvation. This comparative analysis will be important in highlighting the similarities between the two Abrahamic faiths, and that such commonalities can be used as a basis for respect and peaceful co-existence between Christians and Muslims.
This study examines the history of the Jadid movement starting from socio-cultural conditions to the emergence of the jadid movement in Central Asia between the end of the nineteenth century and the beginning of the twentieth century. In order to reach the conclusion about the Jadid movement that it has been formed as the religious-cultural and anti-colonial movement against the Soviet regime, this paper analyses the contest between the traditional Islam scholars and reform-minded intellectuals on the reform ideas. While Khalid argues that the Jadid movement emerged as a cultural and political movement, this paper by examining the Jadidist movement in Central Asia, suggests by adding to the argument of Khalid, that it was formed as a religious-cultural movement. This is because Islam was embedded in the socio-cultural and political life of Central Asian Muslims, and Islam played an integral part in the national identity matter which is inseparable. In other words, Islam was a key marker of Central Asian Muslims' identity. The argument proposed in the study asserts that the Jadid movement, despite its inclination toward secularism and high emphasis on the secular subjects, never detached from the idea of Islam; that is, the Jadids attempted to merge Islam with science and achieve the bygone Islamic civilization and culture of the Golden Age. Thus, throughout the study, it is continually demonstrated that while striving for progress and achievement in the economic and social domains, the Jadids always attempted to preserve Islamic values.
В статье рассматриваются правовые пределы религиоведческой экспертизы и её профилактический потенциал в системе предупреждения деструктивных религиозных идеологий. Исследование основано на догматико-правовом анализе и сопоставлении национальных норм с международными правовыми гарантиями. Институционально-функциональный подход использован для разграничения нормативных функций звеньев системы профилактики. Установлены три правовые и процедурные особенности. Экспертное заключение носит рекомендательный характер, однако имеет юридическое значение для последующих административных решений. Объектом экспертизы является религиозный материал, а не человек. Процедура начинается только при наличии заявления или иного предусмотренного законом основания. Вследствие этого поток поступающих материалов не является репрезентативной выборкой, а сводные результаты не измеряют распространённость деструктивного содержания в обществе и не могут служить целевым индикатором профилактической политики. Научный вклад состоит в конкретизации общего принципа смещения выборки через нормативную конструкцию религиоведческой экспертизы в Казахстане. Предлагается механизм обобщения содержательных признаков из заключений без возможности повторной идентификации лиц и конкретных дел. Его реализация требует специального регулирования защиты персональных данных, ограничения доступа и распространения информации. Согласованность и практическая ценность механизма должны быть проверены в рамках ограниченного пилотного проекта.