Case Report from JAMA Neurology — Leigh Syndrome Associated With Mitochondrial Complex I Deficiency Due to a Novel Mutation in the NDUFS1 Gene

We recently described the genotype/phenotype features of all Spanish patients diagnosed with McArdle disease as of January 2011 (n = 239, prevalence of ~1/167,000) (J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry 2012;83:322–8). Several caveats were however identified suggesting that the prevalence of the disease is actually higher. We have now updated main genotype/phenotype data, as well as potential associations within/between them, of all Spanish individuals currently diagnosed with McArdle disease (December 2016). Ninety-four new patients (all Caucasian) have been diagnosed, yielding a prevalence of ~1/139,543 individuals. Around 55% of the mutated alleles have the commonest PYGM pathogenic mutation p.R50X, whereas p.W798R and p.G205S account for 10 and 9% of the allelic variants, respectively. Seven new mutations were identified: p.H35R, p.R70C, p.R94Q, p.L132WfsX163, p.Q176P, p.R576Q, and c.244-3_244-2CA. Almost all patients show exercise intolerance, the second wind phenomenon and high serum creatine kinase activity. There is, however, heterogeneity in clinical severity, with 8% of patients being asymptomatic during normal daily life, and 21% showing limitations during daily activities and fixed muscle weakness. A major remaining challenge is one of diagnosis, which is often delayed until the third decade of life in 72% of new patients despite the vast majority (86%) reporting symptoms before 20 years. An important development is the growing proportion of those reporting a 4-year improvement in disease severity (now 34%) and following an active lifestyle (50%). Physically active patients are more likely to report an improvement after a 4-year period in the clinical course of the disease than their inactive peers (odds ratio: 13.98; 95% confidence interval: 5.6, 34.9; p < 0.001). Peak oxygen uptake is also higher in the former (20.7 ± 6.0 vs. 16.8 ± 5.3 mL/kg/min, p = 0.0013). Finally, there is no association between PYGM genotype and phenotype manifestation of the disease. The reported prevalence of McArdle disease grows exponentially despite frequent, long delays in genetic diagnosis, suggesting that many patients remain undiagnosed. Until a genetic cure is available (which is not predicted in the near future), current epidemiologic data support that adoption of an active lifestyle is the best medicine for these patients.

Mutations in BCS1L, an assembly factor that facilitates the insertion of the catalytic Rieske Iron‐Sulfur subunit into respiratory chain complex III, result in a wide variety of clinical phenotypes that range from the relatively mild Björnstad syndrome to the severe GRACILE syndrome. To better understand the pathophysiological consequences of such mutations, we studied fibroblasts from six complex III‐deficient patients harboring mutations in the BCS1L gene. Cells from patients with the most severe clinical phenotypes exhibited slow growth rates in glucose medium, variable combined enzyme deficiencies, and assembly defects of respiratory chain complexes I, III, and IV, increased H₂O₂ levels, unbalanced expression of the cellular antioxidant defenses, and apoptotic cell death. In addition, all patients showed cytosolic accumulation of the BCS1L protein, suggestive of an impaired mitochondrial import, assembly or stability defects of the BCS1L complex, fragmentation of the mitochondrial networks, and decreased MFN2 protein levels. The observed structural alterations were independent of the respiratory chain function and ROS production. Our results provide new insights into the role of pathogenic BCS1L mutations in mitochondrial function and dynamics. Hum Mutat 31:–12, 2010.