The article presents selected Polish early warning models (logit and discriminant models) that allow the assessment of the risk of bankruptcy of a company, and the purpose of the considerations is to indicate their prognostic effectiveness in predicting susceptible Polish companies one year before their declarations of bankruptcy. The limitations of these methods were also indicated in unpredictable situations, such as the outbreak of an economic crisis, e.g., caused by a humanitarian crisis—the COVID-19 pandemic. Another aim chosen in the article is a methodological critical assessment of the phenomenon of widespread use of foreign models (including the common Altman method) in the study of the risk of bankruptcy of Polish enterprises. Models developed on a sample of foreign enterprises without prior adaptation to domestic conditions are used all over the world, so the conclusions of the article are applicable internationally. The research was based on a query of Polish and foreign literature in the field of economic and legal aspects of bankruptcy and financial analysis, including, in particular, bankruptcy forecasting. The empirical research analyzes the financial data of 50 Polish enterprises from 2017 to 2018. The effectiveness of the selected bankruptcy forecasting models in identifying enterprises from section C of the Polish economy (industrial processing) that filed for bankruptcy in 2018 and 2019 was tested. The time frame fully allows for the identification and the assessment of the effectiveness of early warning models a year before bankruptcy.
18 December 2018 in Annales Universitatis Mariae Curie-Skłodowska Sectio H – Oeconomia
In Poland, the interest in discriminatory models dates back to 1994 (26 years after the publication of the assumptions of the E. Altman model). The aim of the research was an attempt to critically evaluate, in terms of methodology, the phenomenon of using discriminatory models in the procedure of examining the financial condition of enterprises. The article also attempts to evaluate the state of research in the national literature concerning the subject of discriminatory methods in assessing the financial condition and risk of bankruptcy of enterprises. In the literature, it is still noted that discriminatory methods, from a methodological point of view are unjustifiably described as having a timeless value and sectoral universality. An attempt was made to verify two research theses: the frequency of using particular discriminatory models in the national literature on the subject is not equivalent to a hierarchy of their diagnostic reliability and the discriminatory models do not have the value of sectoral universality. Critical reference was made to numerous cases of simplifications and methodological errors occurring in the national literature on the subject. The research included 132 Polish discriminatory models, the methodological assumptions of which were published in the years 1994–2020, however, for 102 models, the teaching population does not exceed 100 entities. Only in three studies were the number of enterprises higher than 1,000 (they ranged from 1,353 to 11,000). Numerous errors and methodological simplifications have been shown in attempts to apply this method, which reduces the diagnostic credibility of the obtained results, and in extreme cases even disqualifies them. This paradox was also pointed out, as numerous studies have shown that Polish enterprises do not use modern methods of bankruptcy forecasting, or they only apply them sporadically. In the surveyed population of 132 discriminatory models, the most common are the current liquidity ratio (50 models), the rate of return on investment (34), the total debt ratio (31), the asset turnover ratio (29), the ratio of financing assets with working capital (21) and the ratio of financing liabilities with a financial surplus (20).