Patent transfer is a common practice for companies to obtain competitive advantages. However, they encounter the difficulty of selecting suitable patents because the number of patents is increasingly large. Many patent recommendation methods have been proposed to ease the difficulty, but they ignore patent quality and cannot explain why certain patents are recommended. Patent quality and recommendation explanations affect companies’ decision-making in the patent transfer context. Failing to consider them in the recommendation process leads to less effective recommendation results. To fill these gaps, this paper proposes an interpretable patent recommendation method based on knowledge graph and deep learning. The proposed method organizes heterogeneous patent information as a knowledge graph. Then it extracts connectivity and quality features from the knowledge graph for pairs of patents and companies. The former features indicate the relevance of the pairs while the latter features reflect the quality of the patents. Based on the features, we design an interpretable recommendation model by combining a deep neural network with a relevance propagation technique. We conduct experiments with real-world data to evaluate the proposed method. Recommendation lists with varying lengths show that the average precision, recall, and mean average precision of the proposed method are 0.596, 0.636, and 0.584, which improve corresponding performance of best baselines by 7.28%, 18.35%, and 8.60%, respectively. Besides, our method interprets recommendation results by identifying important features leading to the results.
The effectiveness of product recommendations is previously assessed based on recommendation accuracy. Recently, individual diversity and aggregate diversity of product recommendations have been recognized as important dimensions in evaluating the recommendation effectiveness. However, the gain of either diversity is usually at the cost of accuracy and the increase of one diversity does not guarantee a significant improvement in the other. A few attempts have been made to achieve reasonable trade-offs either between recommendation accuracy and individual diversity or between recommendation accuracy and aggregate diversity. Little attention has been paid to obtain a balance among the three important aspects of product recommendations. To address this problem, we propose an adjustable re-ranking approach that incorporates two new ranking criteria for improving both diversities. Three ranking lists are generated to guarantee recommendation accuracy, individual diversity, and aggregate diversity, respectively. The three ranking lists are finally merged with tunable parameters to generate a recommendation list. To evaluate the proposed method, experiments are conducted on a data set obtained from Alibaba. The results show that the proposed method achieves much higher improvements in both diversities than the baseline methods when sacrificing the same amount of recommendation accuracy.
Technologies are one of the most important driving forces of our societal development and realizing the value of technologies heavily depends on the transfer of technologies. Given the importance of technologies and technology transfer, an increasingly large amount of money has been invested to encourage technological innovation and technology transfer worldwide. However, while numerous innovative technologies are invented, most of them remain latent and un-transferred. The comprehension of technical documents and the identification of appropriate technologies for given needs are challenging problems in technology transfer due to information asymmetry and information overload problems. There is a lack of common knowledge base that can reveal the technical details of technical documents and assist with the identification of suitable technologies. To bridge this gap, this research proposes to construct knowledge graph for facilitating technology transfer. A case study is conducted to show the construction of a patent knowledge graph and to illustrate its benefit to finding relevant patents, the most common and important form of technologies.