The bacterium Vibrio parahaemolyticus (Vp) causes gastrointestinal illness in people, generally through the consumption of undercooked or raw seafood. It is a major concern in the oyster industry, especially as the raw oyster market gains in popularity. As a result, a network of adaptive regulations is triggered during times when Vp risk is high (i.e., during warmer temperatures) and reporting requirements to track confirmed infections. A survey of three main stakeholder groups—managers, growers, and restaurants/retail locations—estimated the costs of these regulations for the Washington State oyster industry to quantify their economic burden. Study participants requested that these costs be categorized by actual dollars spent and labor hours needed, and then again by whether those expenses were part of Vp prevention efforts or as the result of a traceable illness. The survey revealed that prevention efforts cost an average $0.45 per dozen oysters landed and a traceable case costs an average of $61,880 for 2019. These costs are largely borne by growers in the form of fixed costs and therefore, there is also an economy of scale at play. The discussion then focuses on how these costs may apply to future management plans and farm budgets, as well as other geographies.
A step-wise approach to implementing ecosystem-based fishery management (EBFM) offers both a tractable policy opportunity and feasible set of scientific responsibilities in ongoing efforts to incorporate ecosystem dynamics into fisheries management. This case study of oysters in the Chesapeake takes a regional approach and utilizes a fishery species that is a popular menu item, an important habitat for other fish species, and a cultural touchstone in the area. From grounding in ecosystem service policy goals and a survey of stakeholders from across industry, management, science, and community groups, we developed eight indicators that are meant to serve as a first-order check for EBFM. We evaluated these indicators based on data availability, spatial coverage of the whole region, and relevance to ecosystem service goals. Spatial integration of indicators addressing chemical, biological, social, and economic factors, allows identification of localities within the region that require more attention, either by scientists or policymakers, in order to meet EBFM goals.
Interdisciplinary science and environmental management involve bringing together data and expertise at multiple spatial scales. The most challenging part of merging scales is aligning the scale of inquiry with the research application. Through the Louisiana case study relating wetland loss and commercial fishing, we examine how the nature and strength of the relationship changes depending on the scale of investigation. Resulting management implications also vary because of tradeoffs in choosing the scale of inquiry. State-level fisheries managers may miss effects of wetland loss in fishing communities because they are looking at aggregate data. Scientific information must directly address the constituent scale, where managers can enact policy. The case study demonstrates why scalar considerations should be an explicit part of the planning process for both science and management.
This article is designed to provide the methodologies used to estimate the impact to the commercial fishing industry as a result of spatial zone management changes within Florida Keys National Marine Sanctuary and its study area, Monroe County, FL. The analysis provided here provides a template for how to estimate economic impacts when refined human use spatial data are not available. Utilizing existing habitat maps and economic data, this method downscales traditional economic methods using a spatial approach to match the fine-scale management approach utilized by the National Marine Sanctuary System. This approach allows the authors to estimate the economic impacts to the commercial fishing sector. The authors find that the proposed spatial zone changes may result in an estimated loss of 42 jobs, with 28 being harvester jobs, to the state of Florida. Additionally, $4.1 million in output and approximately $1.1 million in income may be lost. These estimates do not take into account the likelihood of substitution to alternative fishing grounds or adjusting the target species.
The gold standard for citizen science projects that both integrate multiple ways of knowing and innovate new knowledge and solutions are fully collaborative research endeavors where scientists and citizens work as equals at all stages of research. Beyond equitable structure, there are key factors within each collaborative project that help determine success. Using a case study of a collaborative research project between fishermen and scientists investigating water quality impacts on small-scale fisheries, I highlight these factors which have the potential to elevate citizen science from participation to empowerment: access, space for dissent, structured negotiation, and the role of technology.