In recent years, pea aphids have become major pests of alfalfa. Our previous study found that “Gannong 5” is a highly aphid-resistant alfalfa variety and that “Lie Renhe” is a susceptible one. The average field susceptibility index of “Gannong 5” was 31.31, and the average field susceptibility index of “Lie Renhe” was 80.34. The uptake and balance of amino acids in insects are usually dependent on amino acid transporters. RT-qPCR was used to detect the relative expression levels of seven amino acid transporter differential genes in the different instar pea aphids fed on resistant and susceptible alfalfa varieties after 24 h, and two key genes were selected. When pea aphids fed on “Gannong 5”, the expression of ACYPI004320 was significantly higher than that in pea aphids fed on “Lie Renhe”; however, the expression of ACYPI000536 was significantly lower than that in pea aphids fed on “Lie Renhe”. Afterward, the RNA interference with pea aphid ACYPI000536 and ACYPI004320 genes was performed using a plant-mediated method, and gene function was verified via liquid chromatography–mass spectrometry and pea aphid sensitivity to aphid-resistant and susceptible alfalfa varieties. The results showed that the down-regulation of the ACYPI000536 gene expression led to an increase in the histidine and lysine contents in pea aphids, which, in turn, led to an increase in mortality when pea aphids fed on the susceptible variety “Lie Renhe”. The down-regulation of the ACYPI004320 gene expression led to an increase in phenylalanine content in pea aphids, which, in turn, led to a decrease in mortality when pea aphids fed on the resistant variety “Gannong 5”.