A one-point measurement of net radiation is typically not representative of radiative energy available for the turbulent exchange of latent and sensible heat at eddy-covariance sites with heterogeneous surface cover. We propose a methodology for providing surface-cover-corrected net radiation matching the footprint of turbulent fluxes at a heterogenous eddy-covariance site. This is demonstrated at a complex sub-alpine site in southern central Norway over a week. The methodology is assessed by comparing the energy balance closure calculated with the regular one-point net radiation measurement at the flux tower against the surface-cover-corrected net radiation. The assessment indicates a decrease in the energy imbalance by 8% when assessed with the energy balance ratio, but no improvement is revealed when assessed with regression methods. However, only a small dataset serves as basis for this demonstration, and the findings therefore cannot necessarily be generalized. Further testing and application of the methodology is required to understand the full effect of surface-cover-correcting mismatching footprints of turbulent fluxes and net radiation at heterogeneous eddy-covariance sites.
Changes in vegetation height in the boreal-alpine ecotone are expected over the coming decades due to climate change. Previous studies have shown that subtle changes in vegetation height (<0.2 m) can be estimated with great precision over short time periods (~5 yrs) for small spatial units (~1 ha) utilizing bi-temporal airborne laser scanning (ALS) data, which is promising for operation vegetation monitoring. However, ALS data may not always be available for multi-temporal analysis and other tree-dimensional (3D) data such as those produced by digital aerial photogrammetry (DAP) using imagery acquired from aircrafts and unmanned aerial systems (UAS) may add flexibility to an operational monitoring program. There is little existing evidence on the performance of DAP for height estimation of alpine pioneer trees and vegetation in the boreal-alpine ecotone. The current study assessed and compared the performance of 3D data extracted from ALS and from UAS DAP for prediction of tree height of small pioneer trees and evaluated how tree size and tree species affected the predictive ability of data from the two 3D data sources. Further, precision of vegetation height estimates (trees and other vegetation) across a 12 ha study area using 3D data from ALS and from UAS DAP were compared. Major findings showed smaller regression model residuals for vegetation height when using ALS data and that small and solitary trees tended to be smoothed out in DAP data. Surprisingly, the overall vegetation height estimates using ALS (0.64 m) and DAP data (0.76 m), respectively, differed significantly, despite the use of the same ground observations for model calibration. It was concluded that more in-depth understanding of the behavior of DAP algorithms for small scattered trees and low ground vegetation in the boreal-alpine ecotone is needed as even small systematic effects of a particular technology on height estimates may compromise the validity of a monitoring system since change processes encountered in the boreal-alpine ecotone often are subtle and slow.
The boreal–alpine treeline is a fine-spatial heterogeneous ecotone with small single trees, tree clusters and open snow surfaces during wintertime. Due to climate change and decreased grazing of domestic animals, the treelines expand both upwards into the mountains and northwards into the tundra. To quantify and understand the biophysical radiative climatic feedback effect due to this expansion, it is necessary to establish measurement strategies of fine-spatial albedo by which relationships with the tree structure and snow-masking effect can be quantified. In this study, we measured single-tree Norway spruce albedo for small trees using an unmanned aerial vehicle (UAV). The platform allows the measurement of proximal remotely sensed albedo, enabling the provision of fine-spatial reflectance distributed over larger geographical areas. The albedo measurements varied from 0.39 to 0.99. The interaction between the diurnal course of the sun and sloping terrain constituted the most important driving factor on the albedo. Surprisingly, all tree structural variables revealed smaller correlations with the albedo than typically found for boreal and boreal–alpine summertime albedo. The snow-masking effect of the trees on the albedo was statistically significant and was found to be stronger than the effects of tree structural variables. Only the canopy density had a statistically significant effect on the albedo among the tree structural variables. This was likely explained by the imprecise heading of the hoovering positions of the UAV and insufficient spatial resolution of the reflected radiation measurements. For further development of fine-spatial UAV-measured albedo, we recommend the use of UAVs with high-precision navigation systems and field-stop devices to limit the spatial size of the measured reflected radiation.
9 October 2024 in Agricultural and Forest Meteorology
The albedo of boreal forests depends on the properties of the forest and is a key parameter for understanding the climate impact of forest management practices at high northern latitudes. While high-resolution albedo retrievals from satellites remain challenging, unmanned aerial vehicles (UAVs) offer the ability to obtain albedo corresponding to the typical size of forest stands or even smaller areas, such as forest plots. Plots and pixels of sizes in the typical range of 200–400 m2 are used as the basic units in forest management in the Nordic countries. In this study, the aim was to evaluate the effect of the differences in the footprint size of the measured albedo and fixed-area forest plots on the relationship between albedo and forest attributes. This was performed by examining the correlation between albedo and field-measured forest attributes and metrics derived from airborne laser scanner data using linear regression models. The albedo was measured by a UAV above 400 m2, circular forest plots (n = 128) for seven different flight heights above the top of the canopy. The flight heights were chosen so the plots were always smaller than the footprint of the measured albedo, and the area of a forest plot constituted 30–90% of the measured albedo. The applied pyranometer aboard the UAV measured the albedo according to a cosine response across the footprint. We found the strongest correlation when there was the greatest correspondence between the spatial size of the albedo footprint and the size of the forest plots, i.e., when the target area constituted 80–90% of the measured albedo. The measured albedo of the plots in both regeneration forests and mature forests were highly sensitive (p-values ≤ 0.001) to the footprint size, with a mean albedo difference of 11% between the smallest and largest footprints. The mean albedo of regeneration forests was 33% larger than that of mature forests for footprint sizes corresponding to 90%. The study demonstrates the importance of corresponding spatial sizes of albedo measurements and the target areas subject to measurements.