We study [Roll, R., A mean/variance analysis of tracking error. J. Portfolio Manage., 1992, 18, 13–22.] conjecture that there exists an implicit value in index-tracking (IVIT) relative to forming mean-variance (MV) optimal portfolios under estimation error. We derive an analytical definition for the opportunity cost facing the MV investor who does not index-track. Our findings indicate that the opportunity cost is positive and statistically significant. The existence of an IVIT (positive opportunity cost) is strongly associated with a reduction in the portfolio's induced estimation risk under index-tracking relative to an MV-efficient portfolio of equal target mean return. Under high estimation error cases, increased IVIT translates to higher risk-adjusted returns, lower volatility, higher Sharpe-ratio, lower turnover, and larger certainty equivalent returns. Empirically, a one standard deviation increase in IVIT translates to an annual increase of 4%–5% in the out-of-sample Sharpe-ratio and a 6%–15% decrease in the monthly turnover.
Index funds that track a benchmark, such as the market cap-weighted S&P 500 index, tend to have portfolio holdings biased towards slower-growth large-cap equities that result in the fund’s under-performance, especially in economic downturns. We develop a rigorous quantitative framework that allows dynamic-rebalancing of the allocations such that portfolio exposure in a market segment can change periodically based on economic activity, measured via a set of macro-economic and financial indicators. The method incorporates potential shifts in the economic state, and the likelihood thereof, to determine the fund’s risk orientation optimally in tracking or not tracking the benchmark index. That is, the greater the likelihood of a stronger economic state, the higher the degree of tracking the market index; however, a lack of confidence in the economic state results in a more index-neutral portfolio composition. The proposed smart indexing optimal strategy generates superior risk-adjusted returns consistently in out-of-sample testing, relative to (pure) index tracking. We test several variants and present sensitivity analyses that support our actively-managed smart indexing approach.