This study attempted to improve the polyphenol and volatile aroma compound contents in Nanfeng tangerine wines using non-Saccharomyces yeast and Saccharomyces cerevisiae. The effects of fermentation with pure cultures of Candida ethanolica, Hanseniaspora guilliermondii and Hanseniaspora thailandica, as well as in sequential and mixed inoculations (1:1 or 1:100 ratio) with S. cerevisiae in Nanfeng tangerine wines were evaluated. C. ethanolica was found to produce the most polyphenols (138.78 mg/L) during pure fermentation, while H. guilliermondii produced the most volatile aroma compounds (442.34 mg/L). The polyphenol content produced during sequential fermentation with S. cerevisiae and H. guilliermondii (140.24 mg/L) or C. ethanolica (140.21 mg/L) was significantly higher than other co-fermentations. Meanwhile, the volatile aroma compounds were found to be more abundant in S. cerevisiae/H. guilliermondii mixed fermentation (1:1 ratio) (588.35 mg/L) or S. cerevisiae/H. guilliermondii sequential fermentation (549.31 mg/L). Thus, S. cerevisiae/H. guilliermondii sequential fermentation could considerably boost the polyphenol and volatile aroma component contents in Nanfeng tangerine wines. The findings of this study can be used to drive strategies to increase the polyphenol content and sensory quality of tangerine wines and provide a reference for selecting the co-fermentation styles for non-Saccharomyces yeast and S. cerevisiae in fruit wine fermentation.