Reversible changes in the phosphorylation of reflectin proteins have been shown to drive the tunability of color and brightness of light reflected from specialized cells in the skin of squids and related cephalopods. We show here, using dynamic light scattering, electron microscopy, and fluorescence analyses, that reversible titration of the excess positive charges of the reflectins, comparable with that produced by phosphorylation, is sufficient to drive the reversible condensation and hierarchical assembly of these proteins. The results suggest a two-stage process in which charge neutralization first triggers condensation, resulting in the emergence of previously cryptic structures that subsequently mediate reversible, hierarchical assembly. The extent to which cyclability is seen in the in vitro formation and disassembly of complexes estimated to contain several thousand reflectin molecules suggests that intrinsic sequence- and structure-determined specificity governs the reversible condensation and assembly of the reflectins and that these processes are therefore sufficient to produce the reversible changes in refractive index, thickness, and spacing of the reflectin-containing subcellular Bragg lamellae to change the brightness and color of reflected light. This molecular mechanism points to the metastability of reflectins as the centrally important design principle governing biophotonic tunability in this system.

Discovery that reflectin proteins fill the dynamically tunable Bragg lamellae in the reflective skin cells of certain squids has prompted efforts to design new reflectin-inspired systems for dynamic photonics. But new insights into the actual role and mechanism of action of the reflectins constrain and better define the opportunities and limitations for rationally designing optical systems with reflectin-based components. We and our colleagues have discovered that the reflectins function as a signal-controlled molecular machine, regulating an osmotic motor that tunes the thickness, spacing, and refractive index of the tunable, membrane-bound Bragg lamellae in the iridocytes of the loliginid squids. The tunable reflectin proteins, characterized by a variable number of highly conserved peptide domains interspersed with positively charged linker segments, are restricted in intra- and inter-chain contacts by Coulombic repulsion. Physiologically, this inhibition is progressively overcome by charge-neutralization resulting from acetylcholine (neurotransmitter)-induced, site-specific phosphorylation, triggering the simultaneous activation and progressive tuning of reflectance from red to blue. Details of this process have been resolved through in vitro analyses of purified recombinant reflectins, controlling charge-neutralization by pH-titration or mutation as surrogates for the in vivo phosphorylation. Results of these analyses have shown that neutralization overcoming the Coulombic inhibition reversibly and cyclably triggers condensation and secondary folding of the reflectins, with the emergence of previously cryptic, phase-segregated hydrophobic domains enabling hierarchical assembly. This tunable, reversible, and cyclable assembly regulates the Gibbs-Donnan mediated osmotic shrinking or swelling of the Bragg lamellae that tunes the brightness and color of reflected light. Our most recent studies have revealed a direct relationship between the extent of charge neutralization and the size of the reflectin assemblies, further explaining the synergistic effects on the intensity and wavelength of reflected light. Mutational analyses show that the “switch” controlling reflectins’ structural transitions is distributed along the protein, while detailed comparisons of the sequences and structures of the recently evolved tunable reflectins to those of their ancestral, non-tunable homologs are helping to identify the specific structural determinants governing tunability.

Reflectin proteins are widely distributed in reflective structures in cephalopods. However, only in loliginid squids are they and the subwavelength photonic structures they control dynamically tunable, driving changes in skin color for camouflage and communication. The reflectins are block copolymers with repeated canonical domains interspersed with cationic linkers. Neurotransmitter-activated signal transduction culminates in catalytic phosphorylation of the tunable reflectins' cationic linkers; the resulting charge neutralization overcomes coulombic repulsion to progressively allow condensation, folding, and assembly into multimeric spheres of tunable well-defined size and low polydispersity. Here, we used dynamic light scattering, transmission EM, CD, atomic force microscopy, and fluorimetry to analyze the structural transitions of reflectins A1 and A2. We also analyzed the assembly behavior of phosphomimetic, deletion, and other mutants in conjunction with pH titration as an in vitro surrogate of phosphorylation. Our experiments uncovered a previously unsuspected, precisely predictive relationship between the extent of neutralization of a reflectin's net charge density and the size of resulting multimeric protein assemblies of narrow polydispersity. Comparisons of mutants revealed that this sensitivity to neutralization resides in the linkers and is spatially distributed along the protein. Imaging of large particles and analysis of sequence composition suggested that assembly may proceed through a dynamically arrested liquid–liquid phase-separated intermediate. Intriguingly, it is this dynamic arrest that enables the observed fine-tuning by charge and the resulting calibration between neuronal trigger and color in the squid. These results offer insights into the basis of reflectin-based biophotonics, opening paths for the design of new materials with tunable properties.

Reflectin is a cationic, block copolymeric protein that mediates the dynamic fine-tuning of color and brightness of light reflected from nanostructured Bragg reflectors in iridocyte skin cells of squids. In vivo, the neuronally activated phosphorylation of reflectin triggers its assembly, driving osmotic dehydration of the membrane-bounded Bragg lamellae containing the protein to simultaneously shrink the lamellar thickness and spacing while increasing their refractive index contrast, thus tuning the wavelength and increasing the brightness of reflectance. In vitro, we show that the reduction in repulsive net charge of the purified, recombinant reflectin—either (for the first time) by generalized anionic screening with salt or by pH titration—drives a finely tuned, precisely calibrated increase in the size of the resulting multimeric assemblies. The calculated effects of phosphorylation in vivo are consistent with these effects observed in vitro. The precise proportionality between the assembly size and charge neutralization is enabled by the demonstrated rapid dynamic arrest of multimer growth by a continual, equilibrium tuning of the balance between the protein’s Coulombic repulsion and short-range interactive forces. The resulting stability of reflectin assemblies with time ensures a reciprocally precise control of the particle number concentration, encoding a precise calibration between the extent of neuronal signaling, osmotic pressure, and the resulting optical changes. The charge regulation of reflectin assembly precisely fine-tunes a colligative property-based nanostructured biological machine. A physical mechanism is proposed.