This paper considers investors who are looking to maximize their probability of remaining solvent throughout their lifetime by using an algorithm that aims to optimize their investment allocation strategy and optimize their tax strategy for withdrawal allocations between tax deferred accounts (TDAs), Roth accounts, and taxable stock and bond accounts. This optimization works with stochastic investment returns and stochastic mortality, extending and combining different investment and tax-efficiency paradigms. We find that optimizing the investment strategy has a much larger impact on the investor remaining solvent than optimizing the tax strategy. This result is key to effectively optimizing both strategies simultaneously. This optimized investment strategy soundly beats a standard target date fund strategy, and the novel optimized tax strategy displays optimal desired properties suggested by non-stochastic tax optimization research.
30 November 2021 in The Journal of Wealth Management
We solve a dynamic, long-horizon, goals-based wealth management problem, given different investment regimes. In a world with a good regime (bull market) and a bad regime (bear market), an investor who is cognizant that regime switching occurs has the potential to do better than an investor who assumes only one regime. However, models with more than one regime incur the additional risk of regime uncertainty. Investors must be able to predict which regime is governing the market with reasonable levels of confidence, or they can be worse off than investors who assume just one regime. Using data from recent history, we develop a framework that determines how accurate regime prediction needs to be to achieve gains from a regime-cognizant goals-based investing approach.
Investors planning for retirement balance three Ls: (1) lifestyle risk, hoping to maintain a consumption stream that provides a chosen standard of living; (2) longevity risk, hoping to remain solvent throughout their lifetime; and (3) legacy risk, hoping to leave a bequest to their heirs. We solve this multiple objective problem for a wide range of consumption and annuitization scenarios. For each scenario, we apply dynamic programming to optimally evolve the investments in the non-annuitized portion of the portfolio so as to minimize longevity risk. Our dynamic programming approach has the advantages of (1) generating results that are far superior to what standard Monte Carlo methods, static portfolios, and target date fund glide paths can provide and (2) not requiring utility functions, which are hard to specify for individuals. We show that investors who want to minimize their longevity and legacy risk and who are unable to annuitize their full consumption stream are best off avoiding even partial annuitization of their portfolio. For investors who are able to annuitize their full consumption stream, we quantify their longevity versus legacy risk trade-offs, enabling them to select the best annuity for their needs.
Goals-Based Wealth Management presents a distinct challenge for performance measurement, as conventional investment strategies are typically evaluated based on risk-adjusted returns without explicitly considering the achievement of specific financial goals. Traditional portfolio performance metrics focus on maximizing returns relative to volatility, based purely on the investor risk profile. They often neglect whether these strategies effectively meet the investor’s predefined objectives. Consequently, strategies specifically designed to satisfy financial goals (e.g., goal probability optimization using dynamic programming) may appear to under-perform in some cases when assessed through the traditional lens, despite their alignment with the investor’s long-term priorities. In response to this gap, we propose a risk-sensitive adaptation of the omega ratio that simultaneously accounts for both the probability of goal attainment and the returns generated by a diverse range of investment strategies. We demonstrate that the Risk-Sensitive Omega (RSO) provides a continuous spectrum of preferences between goal achievement and realized returns. The weighting can be determined either by an investor’s risk preferences or by selecting the optimal balance that maximizes the RSO for each individual strategy. By evaluating each strategy at its ideal trade-off between goal probability and returns, we establish a more holistic framework for comparing the performance of competing strategies within the GBWM context, bridging the gap between traditional risk-return assessments and goal-focused investing.