The design of efficient thermal ice protection systems is a challenging task as these systems operate in complex environments involving several coupled physical phenomena such as phase change, boundary-layer flow, and heat transfer. Moreover, certification rules are becoming more stringent, and there is a strong incentive for the reduction of fuel consumption. In this context, numerical tools provide a powerful asset during the design phase but also to gain insight into the physical mechanisms at play. This article presents modeling and simulation strategies for thermal ice protection systems. First, the model describing the behavior of the thermal protection system is presented. Second, a model and associated numerical method is presented for unsteady ice accretion. Third, the coupling methodology between the ice accretion solver and the heat conduction solver is described. In the fourth part, different methods to simulate the boundary-layer flow are described. Finally, some relevant examples are presented, both in steady and unsteady configurations.
This paper presents a new solution method for the calculation of laminar thermal boundary layers. The method consists of a coupling between a modal method (Galerkin method) in the direction normal to the wall and a finite volume method in the direction(s) tangential to the wall. It is similar to an integral method in the sense that only a surface mesh is required and that the unknowns are integral quantities (corresponding to the moments up to a fixed order of the temperature profile in the direction normal to the wall). A specificity of the Galerkin method used is that the domain over which the integrals are computed has a variable size that is also an unknown of the problem. Using a series of numerical tests (representative of situations that can be encountered in aeronautics in the case of a wing equipped with a thermal ice protection system), we show that the new method allows us to predict the quantities of interest with a maximum error of a few percent, while a usual integral method (with only one unknown per mesh cell) is unable to treat the case of boundary layers on heated walls with a strong longitudinal temperature gradient, as shown in the literature.
This paper presents a linear method to postprocess unsteady computations as tied to a fluctuating energy balance. In the field of solid rocket propulsion, this method can be useful to analyze unstable motors with periodic pressure fluctuations within the two-phase flow. It allows one to determine the main fluctuating energy sources in the motor. Derivation of the method is presented in this paper. Moreover, using a simple test case, a fluctuating energy balance approach is compared with a classical linear acoustic balance approach. Both methods produce satisfactory results, but the fluctuating energy balance approach captures more of the physics. Cases, respectively, exhibiting thermoacoustic interaction and parietal vortex shedding are also addressed to show the assets of the fluctuating energy balance approach in comparison with the acoustic balance method.
In-flight ice accretion poses a significant risk to aircraft safety and performance. Despite advancements in ice protection systems, aircraft must demonstrate the ability to operate safely under icing conditions, highlighting the importance of reliable ice accretion simulations. Traditional multistep simulations divide the accretion process into discrete stages, improving the accuracy of ice predictions. However, this approach increases computational costs and reduces automation, as evolving ice shapes necessitate the generation of new grids. This paper investigates the application of immersed boundary methods (IBMs) to eliminate the need for volume remeshing, thereby enhancing the automation of multistep simulations. The proposed framework, integrated into the ONERA three-dimensional (3D) icing suite IGLOO3D, uses a ghost-cell method for modeling airflow and a penalization approach for simulating droplet impingement, building upon recent work by the authors. By relying on inviscid flow simulations, the method significantly reduces computational costs; however, boundary-layer calculations are required. To address this, a 3D simplified integral boundary-layer solver based on the resolution of partial differential equations on a surface is presented. Results from three cases of the 1st Ice Prediction Workshop are presented and analyzed, demonstrating the potential of IBMs to enhance the efficiency and practicality of 3D ice accretion simulations.