Disaster induced and climate related migration and displacement are a crucial issue in the era of climate change. Particularly, human mobility, immobility, and trapped populations are forms of proactive or inactive responses to those negative disturbances. The authors hypothesize that human immobility is deeply rooted in socio-geographical factors such as income, home rental or ownership, insurance coverage, how long one has lived in the area, and previous disaster experiences. This comparative case study was administered at the neighborhood level in Hillsborough County, Florida, which was impacted by Hurricane Irma. The results indicate that new residents who lived in their homes for less than five years were more likely to be non-insurance holders whether they were renters or homeowners. Long term residents, who lived in the same home for more than 13 years, tended to be immobile while holding several types of home insurance coverage. Those who indicated that they do not have home insurance and answered “no idea” when asked whether they will stay in one place or move in years to come have a higher potential to become “trapped” when disaster strikes.
19 August 2022 in International Journal of Disaster Risk Reduction
Purpose: Studies on land acquisition (LA) and recovery simulations have garnered considerable attention amidst climate change. Previous literature has reported that LA and relocation contribute to reducing repetitive disaster losses or downzoning (limiting development). However, studies on decision-making about resettlement or relocation for landowners or decision-makers for disaster-impacted lands are limited. This study aims to qualitatively illustrate LA program schemes for recovery, and identify the underlying concepts of LA in Italy, the United States and Japan. By doing so, this study contributes to construction of future agent-based recovery simulations.Design/methodology/approach: This study seeks to identify a variety of LA models in different contexts to provide input for future works. This study employed multiple case studies to explore common and contrasting results, and identify varied LA concepts. The methodology involved a literature review, including official reports, to examine the timeframes of LA projects qualitatively, complemented using aerial photos to confirm related land use changes pre- and post-LA.Findings: The results indicate that buyout programs in the United States enhance renaturalization in flood-prone areas as a downzoning approach. In contrast, LA in Japan focuses on the continuation of communities or neighborhoods through the recovery and relocation process. In Italy, LA is used to contribute to supporting the tradition/legacy of historic housing and facilities for post-disaster temporary dwellings, reflecting an underlying concept of “tradition and legacy.”Originality/value: This comparative study fills a research gap by focusing on LA concepts, and its novelty lies in finding the underlying concepts of LA in three countries. Through international comparison, it suggests that LA in Japan could incorporate conservation of the historical town center or the opportunity for downzoning.