In this study, a eutectic gallium–indium (EGaIn) alloy and graphene nanoplatelets (GnPs) were employed as reinforcements for a comonomer vinyl ester (cVE) resin at different weight fractions up to 2% via a direct polymerization process. First, the effect of EGaIn on the curing kinetics of cVE was evaluated. The thermal and mechanical properties, and the fracture toughness of two types of cVE composites consisting of EGaIn and GnPs were then studied. The results showed that sub-micron sized EGaIn (≤1 wt.%) could promote the curing reaction of cVE without changing the curing mechanism. However, with further increases in EGaIn loading between 1 and 2 wt.%, the curing reaction rate tends to decrease. Both EGaIn and GnPs showed a significant enhancement in strengthening and toughening the cVE matrix with the presence of filler loading up to 1 wt.%. EGaIn was more effective than GnPs in promoting the flexural and impact strength. An increase of up to 50% and 32% were recorded for these mechanical properties, when EGaln was used, as compared to 46%, and 18% for GnPs, respectively. In contrast, the GnPs/cVE composites exhibited a greater improvement in the fracture toughness and fracture energy by up to 50% and 56% in comparison with those of the EGaIn/cVE ones by up to 32% and 39%, respectively. Furthermore, the stiffness of both the EgaIn/cVE and GnPs/cVE composites showed a significant improvement with an increase of up to 1.76 and 1.83 times in the normalized storage modulus, respectively, while the glass transition temperature (T_g) values remained relatively constant. This work highlights the potential of EGaIn being employed as a filler in creating high-performance thermoset composites, which facilitates its widening applications in many structural and engineering fields, where both higher toughness and stiffness are required.