Teaming a strong preschool with less-developed, rural, or newly established preschools is an effective strategy to promote quality. Since 2015, Shanghai has sought to improve preschool education quality through collaboration. Guided by the “3A2S” theoretical framework, this study evaluated the development and effectiveness of preschool federations in the city using a mixed-methods approach. First, document analysis was conducted to depict features of preschool federations in Shanghai, which identified three main features. Next, a survey study including 702 stakeholders was conducted to assess the evaluations of preschool administrators, teachers, and parents of the effectiveness of preschool federations. Finally, an interview study including 15 stakeholders was conducted to triangulate the findings of the survey study. Results revealed that the stakeholders highly approbated the preschool federations, but parents’ evaluation was significantly lower than that of other stakeholders. Finally, the sustainability and affordability of the preschool federation policy are discussed herein. Implications for policy development and preschool management are also presented.
13 April 2022 in Early Childhood Education Journal
Intergovernmental Relations are conventionally defined as important interactions between governmental units of all types and levels. In the process of universalization of rural preschool education, intergovernmental relations act as an increasingly significant role in facilitating the operating mechanism of vertical institutions at national, provincial, and local levels. This study investigated the policy evolution of intergovernmental relations in the rural preschool educational management system since the founding of the People’s Republic of China. It reveals the developmental tendency of government accountabilities “from involvement to withdrawal and finally to leading”, the focus of government responsibilities “from grassroots institutes to higher-level governments”. The study also explores the influencing mechanisms that affect profound changes in the intergovernmental relations of rural preschool education, and proposes principles of “dominant role of governments, responsibilities heterogeneous at different levels, and appropriate match between administrative power and financial power” to further promote the reform of educational management system in a systematic and sustainable way.