Although most fields of science are constantly struggling with which methodologies to use, the field of systematics, and especially paleontology, has adopted phylogenetic systematics (cladistic methodology) to the exclusion of other approaches. Despite a barrage of cautions and criticism, cladistics reigns. Considered a triumph of the field of paleontology and the crown jewel of cladistic methodology is the proof of the dinosaurian origin of birds. Among the most important features thought to link theropod dinosaurs and birds is a hand reduced to three fingers, a tridactyl hand. We know that the grasping raking hand of theropod dinosaurs is composed of digits 1-2-3, that is, the thumb and the next two fingers, because a variety of late Triassic forms, show digits 4 and 5 having undergone dramatic reduction and remaining only in vestigial form (Fig. 1). Yet virtually all credible developmental studies have concluded that the bird hand is composed of digits 2-3-4. Here, in a provocative theoretical paper, Wagner and Gauthier (1) accept the developmental evidence that birds have a 2-3-4 hand but propose a frame-shift hypothesis, by which the developmental properties responsible for digits (D)1–D3 are shifted onto embryonic precartilaginous condensations (C)2–C4. To put it another way, although these authors accept that the homology of the primordial condensations are correctly identified as C2, C3, and C4, they propose that subsequent anatomical differentiation reflects a frame shift in digit primoidia (anlagen) in later ontogeny such that C2 becomes D1, C3 becomes D2, and C4 becomes D3. By this proposed shift, birds can still be nested in the same clade or monophyletic grouping as maniraptoran theropod dinosaurs (the putative bird ancestors), as concluded by cladistic hypotheses, which date back to a paper by Gauthier (2), generally conceded to be the pivotal paper for this theory. As Neil Shubin (ref. 3, …