Our 2014 hypothesis, published in GENETICS, aimed to elucidate a set of traits associated with mammalian domestication, a phenomenon termed the “domestication syndrome.” Our explanation focused on a special group of cells found in embryos, the neural crest cells (NCCs) and we proposed that genetic changes affecting their development were at the root of vertebrate domestication. We now term this idea the “neural crest/domestication syndrome” (NCDS) hypothesis. In this issue of GENETICS, Johnsson et al. criticize our idea, arguing that it lacked a serious genetic foundation and claiming that, despite many citations, it has received little actual support from new findings. In this reply to their critique, we do three things. First, we note some key facts about animal domestication that need to be recognized in any hypothesis about its genetics. Second, we explain the actual reasoning that led us to propose the NCDS hypothesis. (Johnsson et al....