Forest protection against eastern spruce budworm, Choristoneura fumiferana (Clemens), relies on aerial applications of Bacillus thuringiensis (Btk). However, Btk prescriptions have been developed for balsam fir (Abies balsamea (L.) Mill.) stands, generating uncertainty as to the relevance of this protection approach on white spruce (Picea glauca (Moench) Voss). The main goal of this study was to evaluate the efficacy of three Btk application treatments (early application, late application, and double application) for protecting white spruce and balsam fir in mixed stands. Our results show that all Btk treatments tested kept defoliation under the 50% threshold on balsam fir (27.7 to 38.1% less defoliation than in controls). In contrast, differences in defoliation among treatments were not significant for white spruce. Larval mortality was significantly lower on white spruce than on balsam fir. The low efficacy of Btk treatments on white spruce may be explained by its shoot phenology (most bud caps were still present during the early application), and its foliar chemistry, which could decrease Btk efficacy. Consequently, many larvae may survive simply because Btk spores do not reach them, or because they may consume sublethal doses. We recommend maintaining the current strategy in mixed stands, as it provides a good protection for balsam fir. Further research is needed to determine the causes of the low efficacy of Btk treatments on white spruce.
Annual estimates of defoliation are important tools for managing forest insect defoliators such as the hemlock looper, which feeds on conifer needles of all age classes. We tested the accuracy of defoliation classes obtained from aerial surveys by comparing them with ground-based estimates during a recent outbreak of this insect. We used an approach derived from the Fettes method to estimate defoliation on the current-year shoots as well as on the shoots of the four previous years. Defoliation on the current-year shoots provided accurate estimates of the overall defoliation and the strength of the relationship gradually decreasing for one-year-old to four-year-old foliage. The aerial survey provided accurate estimates of light and moderate defoliation during the first year of the outbreak, but accuracy was lower for both ends of the defoliation gradient and was much less reliable after the second year of the outbreak. All levels of defoliation were then observed in stands where defoliation had not been detected by an aerial survey. Cumulative defoliation on all age classes of foliage brings a new challenge to crews assigned to aerial survey programs. Ground-level defoliation estimates on the current-year shoots can help appraise the risk of tree mortality in the following year.
The bioinsecticide Bacillus thuringiensis subsp. kurstaki (Btk) is applied over large areas to reduce defoliation caused by the spruce budworm, an insect which affects millions of hectares of coniferous forests every 30 to 40 years in eastern North America. The aim of our study was to determine whether, in addition to its direct lethal effects, aerial spraying of Btk had sublethal effects on spruce budworm populations and their parasitism. Four sites were sprayed with Btk and compared to four control sites in two regions, one where the outbreak had started three years earlier and the other where it had been going on for 10 years. Insects were collected to compare budworm pupal mass and parasitism at different stages (L5, L6 and pupae). Budworm pupae were significantly lighter in Btk-treated sites than in controls, and in the older population than in the younger one. However, pupae collected from Btk-treated sites had the same mass in both regions, suggesting a minimum pupal mass threshold, which may affect population dynamics. Larval parasitism was low, but pupal parasitism was high and strongly influenced by an interaction between Btk and region, with a higher parasitism observed in Btk-treated sites of the younger population than in those of the older population. A significant interaction was observed between Btk treatment and region on the proportion of larvae that failed to complete development, which was particularly high in Btk-treated sites of the older population. Our study confirms the effectiveness of Btk in controlling spruce budworm populations directly but also indirectly through sublethal effects on budworm development, capacity to complete development, pupal size and parasitism. To maximize control efficacy, the timing of Btk applications could vary according to the age of populations during the budworm outbreak cycle.
Norway spruce (Picea abies (L.) Karst.) has been widely planted beyond its natural range due to its fast growth rate and valuable wood. In Québec, over 200 million seedlings have been planted since 1964. Several of these plantations are now facing a new potential threat, i.e., spruce budworm (Choristoneura fumiferana (Clem.)) infestations. Despite contrasting results, Norway and white spruce (P. glauca [Moench] Voss) apparently sustain a similar degree of budworm defoliation. The main study objective is to quantify defoliation in Norway spruce caused by spruce budworm. We also evaluate the efficacy of Bacillus thuringiensis Berliner spp. kurstaki (Btk) in protecting this exotic host tree. Annual defoliation was assessed in plantations of Norway, white, and black spruce (P. mariana [Mill.] BSP) between 2018 and 2022 in the Bas-Saint-Laurent region. Additional surveys were conducted in Norway and white spruce plantations in the Gaspésie and Côte-Nord to evaluate Btk efficacy. We show that both species exhibit similar defoliation levels, though Norway spruce sometimes sustains greater damage (e.g., 35% vs. 10% in 2019). Btk formulations showed low efficacy in protecting Norway spruce foliage (≥49.32% defoliation in treated plantations). Further studies are needed to understand factors influencing Btk efficacy on this host.