Purpose: The B onferroni correction adjusts probability ( p ) values because of the increased risk of a type I error when making multiple statistical tests. The routine use of this test has been criticised as deleterious to sound statistical judgment, testing the wrong hypothesis, and reducing the chance of a type I error but at the expense of a type II error; yet it remains popular in ophthalmic research. The purpose of this article was to survey the use of the B onferroni correction in research articles published in three optometric journals, viz. O
phthalmic &
P
hysiological
O
ptics
, O
ptometry &
V
ision
S
cience
, and C
linical &
E
xperimental
O
ptometry
, and to provide advice to authors contemplating multiple testing. Recent findings: Some authors ignored the problem of multiple testing while others used the method uncritically with no rationale or discussion. A variety of methods of correcting p values were employed, the B onferroni method being the single most popular. B onferroni was used in a variety of circumstances, most commonly to correct the experiment‐wise error rate when using multiple ‘ t ’ tests or as a post‐hoc procedure to correct the family‐wise error rate following analysis of variance ( anova ). Some studies quoted adjusted p values incorrectly or gave an erroneous rationale. Summary: Whether or not to use the B onferroni correction depends on the circumstances of the study. It should not be used routinely and should be considered if: (1) a single test of the ‘universal null hypothesis’ ( H o ) that all tests are not significant is required, (2) it is imperative to avoid a type I error, and (3) a large number of tests are carried out without preplanned hypotheses.
17 December 2012 in Ophthalmic and Physiological Optics
Purpose: Measurements obtained from the right and left eye of a subject are often correlated whereas many statistical tests assume observations in a sample are independent. Hence, data collected from both eyes cannot be combined without taking this correlation into account. Current practice is reviewed with reference to articles published in three optometry journals, viz., O phthalmic and P hysiological O ptics ( OPO ), O ptometry and V ision S cience ( OVS ), C linical and E xperimental O ptometry ( CEO ) during the period 2009–2012. Recent findings: Of the 230 articles reviewed, 148/230 (64%) obtained data from one eye and 82/230 (36%) from both eyes. Of the 148 one‐eye articles, the right eye, left eye, a randomly selected eye, the better eye, the worse or diseased eye, or the dominant eye were all used as selection criteria. Of the 82 two‐eye articles, the analysis utilized data from: (1) one eye only rejecting data from the adjacent eye, (2) both eyes separately, (3) both eyes taking into account the correlation between eyes, or (4) both eyes using one eye as a treated or diseased eye, the other acting as a control. In a proportion of studies, data were combined from both eyes without correction. Summary: It is suggested that: (1) investigators should consider whether it is advantageous to collect data from both eyes, (2) if one eye is studied and both are eligible, then it should be chosen at random, and (3) two‐eye data can be analysed incorporating eyes as a ‘within subjects’ factor.
18 August 2019 in Ophthalmic and Physiological Optics
Purpose: To survey the use of Pearson's correlation coefficient ( r ) and related statistical methods in the ophthalmic literature, to consider the limitations of r , and to suggest suitable alternative methods of analysis. Recent findings: Searching
Ophthalmic and Physiological Optics (
OPO
), Optometry and Vision Science (
OVS
), and Clinical and Experimental Optometry (
CXO
)
online archives using correlation and Pearson's r as search terms resulted in 4057 and 281 hits respectively. C oefficient of determination , r square , or r squared received fewer hits (65, 8, and 22 hits respectively). The assumption that r follows a bivariate normal distribution was rarely encountered (3 hits) although several studies applied Spearman's rank correlation (70 hits). The
intra‐class correlation coefficient (
ICC
)
was widely used (178 hits), but fewer hits were recorded for partial correlation (43 hits) and multiple correlation (13) hits. There was little evidence that the problem of sample size was addressed in correlation studies. Summary: Investigators should be alert to whether: (1) the relationship between two variables could be non‐linear, (2) the data are bivariate normal, (3) r accounts for a significant proportion of the variance in Y , (4) outliers are present, the data are clustered, or have a restricted range, (5) the sample size is appropriate, and (6) a significant correlation indicates causality. In addition, the number of significant digits used to express r and the problems of multiple testing should be addressed. The problems and limitations of r suggest a more cautious approach regarding its use and the application of alternative methods where appropriate.
Since the earliest descriptions of Alzheimer’s disease (AD), many theories have been advanced as to its cause. These include: (1) exacerbation of aging, (2) degeneration of anatomical pathways, including the cholinergic and cortico-cortical pathways, (3) an environmental factor such as...
28 February 2018 in Clinical and Experimental Optometry
This review describes the oculo-visual problems likely to be encountered in Parkinson’s disease (PD) with special reference to three questions: (1) are there visual symptoms characteristic of the prodromal phase of PD, (2) is PD dementia associated w