In this study, prospective teachers engaged in professional noticing of their students’ mathematical thinking captured in pieces of written work. Researchers then worked to characterize the prospective teachers’ professional noticing using a lens of responsive teaching. Results indicate that prospective teacher decisions about how to respond to their students’ mathematical thinking fall on a responsiveness continuum, often shifting in responsiveness across pieces of student written work. The findings of this study provide guidance for teacher educators who work to develop K–12 educators’ responsive teaching practices.
This study examines instructional reasoning in an approximation of practice that simulates a teacher sitting down after class to examine students’ written work. The participants were prompted to attend to, interpret, and decide how to respond to student thinking contained in a piece of written work. Our purpose was to capture the additional cognitive work that teachers engage in. Using qualitative content analysis, we identified the most frequent types of instructional reasoning used by expert teachers just prior to engaging in a responsive deciding action about how to respond. We used the results of our analysis to present three illustrative cases of responsive instructional reasoning.
10 January 2026 in Ohio Journal of School Mathematics
This article examines prospective teachers' reported experiences and perceptions as they used a standardized prompt with the free version of ChatGPT (ChatGPT-3.5, OpenAI, 2024) to analyze and respond to elementary students' work on high cognitive demand mathematics tasks. The purpose of this study is to contribute to understanding how AI tools, rather than replacing teacher expertise, might act as pedagogical support to enhance prospective teachers' abilities to analyze and respond to student thinking in ways that maintain cognitive demand and extend mathematical understanding (National Council of Teachers of Mathematics, 2024). Results indicated that prospective teachers perceived that ChatGPT did support their analysis and responses in ways responsive to their students' thinking. Results also demonstrated three distinct types of questions generated by ChatGPT that emerged from the prospective teachers' experiences working with elementary students: advancing, clarifying, and extending. Implications and discussion focus on the potential of using ChatGPT to support specific aspects of responsive teaching.