Purpose: This paper investigates the relationship between market power and efficiency for Indian banks in order to test the validity of the quiet life hypothesis (QLH) during 2005–2019.Design/methodology/approach: First, the bank-level DEA efficiency scores and three measures of the Lerner index: traditional, efficiency-adjusted, stochastic are estimated. Then, efficiency scores are regressed on Lerner indices plus a set of banking and economic control variables.Findings: Robust evidence against the QLH is obtained. Moreover, the conventional Lerner index suggests that market power of Indian banks, as well as of the different bank groups, increased during the study period, due to a greater reduction in costs compared to that of the price of banking services. The efficiency scores also declined for the banking system as a whole, and for all bank groups except new private banks.Originality/value: This is the first study testing the QLH for the different categories of Indian banks and also provides robust inferences by using both stochastic and non-stochastic measures of market power.
This paper investigates income convergence of Indian states in the post-reform period when markets played a greater role in resource allocation. We analyze stochastic convergence of relative per capita incomes of 19 states for the period 1994–2018 by employing a recently developed panel data approach controlling for structural breaks as smooth shifts. Smooth shifts are modelled using a more flexible Fourier approach that does not require identifying the number, date, and form of breaks. The empirical results, contrary to recent empirical findings, do not support evidence in favour of convergence in per capita income among Indian states. Poor infrastructure, lack of adequate financial development, and weak governance structure coupled with low total factor productivity growth seem to be responsible for the divergence of income. The findings suggest that development intervention in the post-reform period has neither been of the required order nor in the desired direction to help the lagging states to catch up with the leading ones.
I. The Quiet Life Hypothesis (QLH) by Hicks (1935) posits that firms enjoying market power need not pursue profitability but prefer to be inefficient. The QLH, when applied to banking, points to th...