Augmented reality game-based learning has become an emerging trend in the field of education as it has the potential to increase children's learning motivation for subjects such as mathematics. However, to achieve the benefits for children effectively, AR serious games need to be appropriately designed, especially in respect to their novel interactions and representation paradigms. In this paper, we report on an exploratory experiment to investigate how different interaction techniques (digital screen-touch interaction vs real-world tangible interaction) and different feedback mechanisms (non-diegetic feedback vs diegetic feedback) affect 7-8-year-old children's motivation for mathematics learning. Our results show that diegetic feedback led to the game being considered significantly more enjoyable, as well as inducing greater feelings of competence and autonomy; screen-touch interaction versus tangible interaction did not change motivation directly, nor did we find interaction effects between the presentation and interaction modes. By analyzing the results and based on previous studies, we identify recommendations for designers to develop motivating serious AR games for children.
(1) Background: Augmented reality (AR) game-based learning, has received increased attention in recent years. Fantasy is a vital gaming feature that promotes engagement and immersion experience for children. However, situating learning with AR fantasy to engage learners and fit pedagogical contexts needs structured analysis of educational scenarios for different subjects. (2) Methods: We present a combined study using our own built AR games, MathMythosAR2 for mathematics learning, and FancyBookAR for English as second-language learning. For each game, we created a fantasy and a real-life narrative. We investigated player engagement and teachers’ scaffolding through qualitative and quantitative research with 62 participants aged from 7 to 11 years old. (3) Results: We discovered that fantasy narratives engage students in mathematics learning while disengaging them in second-language learning. Participants report a higher imagination with fantasy narratives and a higher analogy with real-life narratives. We found that teachers’ scaffolding for MathMythosAR2 focused on complex interactions, for FancyBookAR, focused on story interpretation and knowledge explanation. (4) Conclusions: It is recommended to mix fantasy and real-life settings, and use simple AR interaction and pedagogical agents that enable teachers’ scaffolding seamlessly. The design of AR fantasy should evaluate whether the story is intrinsically related to the learning subjects, as well as the requirements of explicit explanation.
Contemporary young generations face numerous 21st-century learning challenges, including motivation deficiency, distraction, low effectiveness, etc. Fantasy in game-based learning, creating imaginative and fictional situations that deviate from real-life has demonstrated powerful effects on engaging young participants. Fantasy in games empowered by Augmented Reality (AR) can further immerse participants by generating a "magic circle" where the boundary of digital fantasy and the physical real world is blurred. Despite these positive potentials, there are still concerns regarding the effect of fantasy on player experience, educational contextual adaptation, learning motivation, and learning effect. In this work, we explore the effect of Fantasy in Augmented Reality game-based learning from a player journey perspective, which contains four phases. Four phases are analyzed through an empirical study for each phase. In each study, the effects of fantasy and real-life versions are compared. The purpose of this work is to gain a deeper understanding of the impact of fantasy in AR game-based learning and to provide designers with effective design strategies that help learners overcome the challenges of 21st-century learning.