To promote the development of the Green Building (GB) concept in developing countries, this paper treated the combination of the scientometric analysis of green building research in the Middle East and North Africa (MENA) region, with investigation into the current state of deployment of GB and barriers to sustainable construction practices in the Moroccan construction industry. A scientometric method was used to analyze 159 articles published from 2000 to 2021, and a survey of 167 Moroccan professionals with green building experience was conducted to understand the stakeholders’ position. The examination of the dataset reveals the significant contribution in GB research from Gulf countries (Saudi Arabia with 27 articles). The adoption of GB in the Moroccan construction industry is not apparent. Four clusters for the twelve barriers have been identified by the clustering analysis. They were attributed to government, social and awareness barriers, design phase barriers, high initial costs, and technology barriers. This paper provides stakeholders with the necessary knowledge and understanding of the current research, its gaps, inter-regional and international cooperation, and future direction in the MENA region. This could aid practitioners and policymakers in taking the proper actions to mitigate obstacles for GB adoption.
The method presented in this paper provides for the deployment of a sustainability assessment of residential buildings in local contexts in Morocco. The main purpose is to develop a description sheet for each criterion for 29 subcategories of the “Moroccan Building Sustainability Assessment Framework,” environmental dimension (MBSAF(Env)). Firstly, a set of indicators with possible measures was identified; then, we reviewed national standards and existing green building rating systems. Then, several discussions involving a panel of experts (e.g., engineers, academics) were conducted to consolidate the threshold assessment. The main purpose is scored using a rating scale-based sustainability assessment procedure that is specifically designed for the assessment of new and existing Moroccan residential buildings. • MBSAF(Env) consoled risk management and adaptation of climate change indicators. • The framework provides an adaptability for new and existing residential buildings, taking the regionalization contexts of Morocco. • All criteria and indicator ratings are represented within a −1 to 5-point scale, and their thresholds are identified by national and international standards.
Purpose: The increasing adoption of Green Building Rating Systems (GBRSs) has introduced significant methodological diversity into sustainability assessments, raising concerns about the comparability and robustness of evaluation outcomes. This study aimed to evaluate the environmental dimensions of the Moroccan Building Sustainability Assessment Framework (MBSAF(Env)) and examine its methodological positioning relative to established international systems, namely, the Building Research Establishment Environmental Assessment Method (BREEAM), Leadership in Energy and Environmental Design (LEED) and High Environmental Quality (HQE). Design/methodology/approach: A comparative multi-assessment approach was employed, applying the MBSAF(Env) and three international GBRSs (BREEAM, LEED and HQE) to two residential buildings. The analysis focused on cross-system variations at both category and overall rating levels, with particular attention paid to scoring mechanisms, normative references, and calculation procedures. Findings: The results revealed substantial variability across systems. An inter-project performance gap of up to 52 percentage points was observed, whereas cross-system differences exceeded 100 percentage points in categories such as water and waste. In contrast, the energy performance exhibited relative convergence, with variations limited to approximately three percentage points. The analysis further highlights the influence of penalty-based scoring mechanisms, with negative contributions observed in the MBSAF(Env) (down to −1.15%). These findings demonstrate that assessment outcomes are not solely determined by building performance but are strongly influenced by the structural configuration of the evaluation methodologies. Originality/value: This study proposes a tripartite analytical framework based on scoring architecture, normative anchoring, and methodological institutionalization to support the interpretation of variability across GBRSs. It provides novel empirical and conceptual insights into the interactions between local and international frameworks and challenges the validity of direct cross-system comparisons.